Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Bow Attacks not calculating "Bow Attacks fire an Additional Arrow" or "Bow Attacks fire 2 Additional Arrows" #783

Open
3 tasks done
John-The-Tripper opened this issue Feb 14, 2025 · 2 comments

Comments

@John-The-Tripper
Copy link

Check version

  • I'm running the latest version of Path of Building and I've verified this by checking the changelog

Check for duplicates

  • I've checked for duplicate open and closed issues by using the search function of the issue tracker

Check for support

  • I've checked that the calculation is supposed to be supported. If it isn't please open a feature request instead (Red text is a feature request).

What platform are you running Path of Building on?

Windows

What is the value from the calculation in-game?

The calculation is also missing in game from my research. For example, I have a Dual-string bow with suffix to fire another arrow for a total of 4 arrows. The Lightning Arrow skill information shows that it's only firing 2. I believe this issue is both game client side and in PoB.

What is the value from the calculation in Path of Building?

The damage per second value is not modified by adjusting a bow from only firing one additional arrow to two. In my test case I fire 4 arrows and an upgrade would see me firing 5 arrows for an increase of 20% DPS (or 25%, I suck at math). But in testing and manually modifying an imported Bow from PoE2 I've found no change to the damage profile.

How to reproduce the issue

  1. Ranger with Deadeye Ascendency and "Endless Munitions"
  2. Dual-string Bow with Suffix "Bow Attacks Fire an Additional Arrow"
  3. Copy bow to PoB2
  4. Edit bow to have Suffix "Bow Attacks Fire 2 Additional Arrows" and remove "Bow Attacks Fire an Additional Arrow"

PoB for PoE2 build code

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

Screenshots

Base

Image

Modified

Image

@Blitz54
Copy link
Contributor

Blitz54 commented Feb 14, 2025

The DPS only calculates per one projectile. Both in game and in PoB. It's impossible to know how many of your projectiles hit the enemy, so it gives a baseline assuming one. Most of the time you wouldn't be hitting an enemy with every arrow anyway, unless you were extremely close up, or it's a large enemy like a boss.

If you check your Calc tab and look at Skill type-specific Stats, you can see the projectile count. If you want to see the DPS when every arrow hits the enemy (like a big fat boss), you can increase the count of lighting arrow in the Skills tab, and click the "Full DPS" checkbox. Full DPS will show up on the left near the bottom.

Image

@SiderealDay
Copy link

Is it true that even when you have multiple arrows, only a single projectle from LA will hit one target? I read you cannot shotgun with it, even on big hitbox of a boss.
However, Lightning Rod does benefit from extra arrows. Is that calculated properly in PoB?

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

3 participants