Calendar disabled state: Month/Year Selects remain interactive while chevrons are disabled

[Arthikumari02]

I noticed an inconsistency in the Calendar disabled state.

Observed behavior
When the Calendar is disabled:

• Month Select remains interactive.
• Year Select remains interactive.
• Previous/Next chevron buttons are disabled.

Expected behavior
Since all of these controls are used for calendar navigation, I would expect them to behave consistently when the Calendar is disabled.

Either:

• All navigation controls should be disabled, or
• All navigation controls should remain interactive.

Question
Is this behavior intentional, or should the Month/Year Select controls also be disabled when the Calendar is disabled?

Tested on react-aria-components 1.18.0.

[snowystinger]

Given that the < and > buttons are disabled, I think the pickers should be disabled too. Or maybe replaced by the text
https://stackblitz.com/edit/hc6hqqme?file=src%2FExample.tsx

It might be a little strange though because while all the rest of the calendar is disabled and doesn't meet contrast, the week days and the title are still visible if you just make a calendar disabled
https://react-aria.adobe.com/Calendar
Whereas with the disabled Selects, the only thing that would still be meeting contrast would be the week days.

[Arthikumari02]

Got it, thanks. I agree that keeping the navigation controls consistent seems more intuitive. The contrast/styling concerns make sense, but it sounds like the current behavior is likely an inconsistency rather than an intentional distinction.