Tensorflow and Keras compatible versions for Cleverhans==3.1.0

[tekeuange23]

Problem

Python==3.6.13 , Tensorflow==2.1.0 , Keras==2.2.0

ERROR: AttributeError: module 'tensorflow' has no attribute 'GraphKeys'

Python==3.11.5 , Tensorflow==2.13.0 , Keras==2.13.1 , cleverhans==4.0.0

- impossible to use the jsma
- can't: from cleverhans.attacks import fgsm , jsma
- can't: from cleverhans.utils_tf import model_train , model_eval , batch_eval
- can't: from cleverhans.attacks_tf import jacobian_graph
- can't: from cleverhans.utils import other_classes

Question

Which version of the following libraries goes perfectly with cleverhans==3.1.0

• Tensorflow
• Keras
• Python

cc @goodfeli @carlini @npapernot

[Mubarak-AbduAguye]

Hello @tekeuange23 ,
From the project homepage (https://github.com/cleverhans-lab/cleverhans) it seems CleverHans 3.1 was designed to work with Tensorflow 1 versions, and both TF1 and CleverHans 3.1 are no longer maintained. You will probably have an easier time migrating to TF2 if that is possible for your goal. I can confirm that most TF2 versions (at least from TF2.7 upwards) directly support CleverHans 4.0 out of the box.

In the meantime, if you absolutely have to use CleverHans 3.1, then shooting for TF1.12 or so (and its associated Keras version) might be a good start.

Good luck!