How to use "-extra" base image via InvariantGlobalization?

[mu88]

Hi @baronfel,

When using the .NET SDK Container Building Tools and setting the MSBuild property InvariantGlobalization to false, the base image with the -extra suffix is not used:

Based on the log statement Using user-provided ContainerFamily, I was able to find this spot in the code.
However, I'm wondering about why I'm not ending up here 🤔

Do you have a hint for me?

Here's my repro workflow:

1. dotnet new webapi
2. dotnet publish /t:PublishContainer /p:InvariantGlobalization=false /p:ContainerRuntimeIdentifier=linux-x64 /p:ContainerFamily=noble-chiseled /bl
3. Open the MSBuild log with MSBuild Structured Log Viewer

[baronfel]

Oh this is a really dumb bug - we're comparing the major version of the 'parsed TFM' value to the first version where the extras became available. So the following code:

&& (!parsedVersion.IsPrerelease && parsedVersion.Major == FirstVersionWithNewTaggingScheme)) //

translates as:

true && false

This is a straight-up bug.

[mu88]

Thank you!

[baronfel]

Closing this discussion as we have a full issue + PR for this now. Thanks for bringing this up @mu88!

[Frulfump]

Link?

[baronfel]

Oh, I assumed using 'Create issue from Discussion' would have made as association of some kind. Ah well - here it is: #52160