Skip to content

Confusing behavior when using star globs and list indexing #166

@igordertigor

Description

@igordertigor

When using dpath.util.search retrieves an empty list, it won't include it in the result:

>>> import dpath.util
>>> a = {'a': {'b': []}}
>>> b = {'a': {'b': [1, 2, 3]}}
>>> dpath.util.search(a, 'a/b/*')  # expecting {'a': {'b': []}} here
{}
>>> dpath.util.search(b, 'a/b/*', afilter=x > 3 if isinstance(x, int) else True)   # should again give {'a': {'b': []}}
{}
>>> dpath.util.search(a, 'a/b')
{'a': {'b': []}}

I find this behaviour counterintuitive: I tend to "pronounce" the star as "give me all items in this location". Hence if the item is an empty list, then I want that empty list. Am I misunderstanding something here? What would be the expected behaviour? Also, the final call illustrates something that I find particularly strange here: I would think of both globs to give the same results, but they don't seem to do so.

A second confusing thing seems to be the handling of numeric indexes for lists:

>>> dpath.util.search(b, 'a/b/0')
{'a': {'b': [1]}}
>>> dpath.util.search(b, 'a/b/-1')  # expecting {'a': {'b': [3]}} here.
{}

How would I pass negative indexes? Is that supported at all?

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Type

No type

Projects

No projects

Milestone

No milestone

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions