Is Titan Dead?

[codeclinic]

It'd be great if people could get some clarity on whether Titan is dead or not. A lot of people rely on this plugin and it's lack of updates is causing end users to uninstall our plugins and themes because they see that Titan hasn't been updated for a year or more.

I'm more than happy to come on board as maintainer &/or take over the plugin if you no longer have time to ma
intain it.

[codeclinic]

I'm trying to resurrect this framework. Please follow my repo and let's get this thing active again.

https://github.com/codeclinic/Abased-Titan-Framework

Thanks
Phill

[bfintal]

Hello, yes unfortunately I don’t have the time anymore to maintain the plugin :(

[codeclinic]

@bfintal Would you consider making me the maintainer or giving me the relevant admin permissions, then I can try and take it on?

[TreyOverton]

If you don't have time, then do those of us who committed to using the plugin a favor and let Phill take it over. It's irresponsible to promote a thing, get a bunch of people using it, then abandon it while also retaining sole control. Phill's already created a fork, but that adds complexity when getting to the exact same goal anyway - a supported plugin without the known bugs.

…

On Sat, Dec 7, 2019 at 5:18 AM Benjamin Intal ***@***.***> wrote: Hello, yes unfortunately I don’t have the time anymore to maintain the plugin :( — You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#426?email_source=notifications&email_token=ACSVXIURRKHEY6FERID5A6LQXOPATA5CNFSM4JUUSGC2YY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOEGGGWMY#issuecomment-562850611>, or unsubscribe <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ACSVXIQDLZXRO4Y6VJ2LYADQXOPATANCNFSM4JUUSGCQ> .

[codeclinic]

Sadly it would appear the current maintainer wants to sell the plugin. For the amount of work involved in getting this up to a decent standard it's not conceivable for me to purchase this from @gambitph On Mon, Dec 9, 2019 at 7:20 PM +0100, "Aaron Overton" <notifications@github.com> wrote: If you don't have time, then do those of us who committed to using the plugin a favor and let Phill take it over. It's irresponsible to promote a thing, get a bunch of people using it, then abandon it while also retaining sole control. Phill's already created a fork, but that adds complexity when getting to the exact same goal anyway - a supported plugin without the known bugs. Blue skies,

…

-Aaron

[TreyOverton]

How much does he want for his open source plugin that anyone can just take as is and market? When WooThemes asked to buy Jigoshop, they offered an amount. Jigoshop got insulted and demanded something more, like maybe 10x as much. So WooThemes simply forked the code, paid them nothing, and hired their top programmer away. Eventually, Automattic bought them out and WooCommerce became effectively part of core. Seems like a losing proposition and if that's the plan, then it's time to fork and move on.

…

On Mon, Dec 9, 2019 at 10:27 AM Phill Healey ***@***.***> wrote: Sadly it would appear the current maintainer wants to sell the plugin. For the amount of work involved in getting this up to a decent standard it's not conceivable for me to purchase this from @gambitph

[codeclinic]

Don’t know how much he wants. I’m not prepared to ask. I’m a bit insulted to be honest. This thing has been dead for ages, and loads of people are stuck with it having spent time and money incorporating it. I spent ages trying to get some response about the plugin with no luck, then all of a sudden I get a message asking if I want to buy it. How much does he want for his open source plugin that anyone can just take as is and market? When WooThemes asked to buy Jigoshop, they offered an amount. Jigoshop got insulted and demanded something more, like maybe 10x as much. So WooThemes simply forked the code, paid them nothing, and hired their top programmer away. Eventually, Automattic bought them out and WooCommerce became effectively part of core. Seems like a losing proposition and if that's the plan, then it's time to fork and move on. Blue skies, -Aaron

[codeclinic]

To be honest, the website wouldn’t be a problem for me to setup either and likewise it’d give a bit of traffic & seo value back to myself. I also have hosting infrastructure already setup. However, If you want to pay for Titan then I guess that’d be your privilege. Eitherway, I guess that's something for discussion further down the line if this goes anywhere.

[bfintal]

I'm sorry but please do not misconstrue my words. You do not need to be insulted since I did not ask you to buy it. Please read again what I sent you. Here it is so that everyone can see:

I was actually planning on putting up Titan for sale since I couldn't maintain it anymore.

I did not post this reply in this issue and sent it in private since I didn't find it appropriate to post the plan here. But we're talking about the topic now anyway.

As for any details about this, to be honest this was just the plan but no specifics yet really. But probably when I get some free time again, I'd like to address the immediate problems of Titan and update it to a state that's stable again - no new features, just make it up-to-date. Then proceed from there.

I have poured tons of hours in this OSS / plugin, and never saw a dime from this project. It's been quite a while since we've used/updated it, so it's harder to maintain now. Realistically, I can't maintain this project since I have to focus on those that bring food to the table. But this was one of my first big project that gained somewhat of a traction, so Titan has always been special to me.

[TreyOverton]

Ben: totally valid perspective. But you're forgetting that people started depending on your work and now you can't maintain it, but also won't let others maintain it. You undo a great thing by a desire to not let go.

"When I get some free time again..." Last time that happened was October 2018. You just need to recognize that could totally be "never." And because it's all GPL and Open Source, you can either open it up and allow people to help you, or just face that at any moment someone will simply fork the code and run with it.

The option to be fully in control requires you to be actively maintaining. You can't, so you can either retain some control with help or have zero control because you just won't and people will take matters into their own hands without you. I think your watershed moment has arrived.

[pagelab]

It's really troublesome when things like these happens. I personally considered using Titan some years ago, but decided to choose another framework, that is still being actively maintained. I'm glad I have chosen the other option TBH.

But let's not forget that this is an Open Source project (GPLv2). So, by definition, you or anyone can fork it right now and build on top of it. You don't need special authorization from @bfintal to do this. It's the nature of FLOSS. Just remember to keep any copyright messages and refrain to use the “Titan” branding at all on the fork. The project's code and the brand are two separate things.

Also, anyone that uses a GPLv2 project like Titan should be aware that there's absolutely no guarantees in using it. This is explicitly said in the license's text.

So, the reality is that @bfintal is not obliged (legally, morally or otherwise) to give any kind of support or even maintain the project. It's his call.

[codeclinic]

@pagelab That's true and if you'd read the threads it would be clear to you that this has already been discussed. However, you would also notice that the issue is that @bfintal isn't prepared to let anyone else take over this project. Regardless of the listing on the WordPress plugins directory, it introduces a lot of issues with taking this forward if we are required to fork the project and then somehow encourage the community to follow us. This is especially true when considering the time, effort and to a degree trust that people have put into adopting this framework and using it in their products.

Simply handing the project over to new maintainers would enable the project to best honour @bfintal 's project& all his time and hard work by allowing us to keep it alive. in its current form and thus minimise the impact on those invested in Titan. Thus, maximizsing the potential for titan to live on in some working form.

[bfintal]

“Isn’t prepared” is probably the perfect way to way to say it @codeclinic. I’d like to take a stab at it though to bring the project forward.

[milojennings]

I'd really like to see this project taken over and maintained by the community. It's a great framework.
Unfortunately, my company is at a crossroads and will probably have to go a different direction with future projects due to the state of this project.

[milojennings]

I personally considered using Titan some years ago, but decided to choose another framework, that is still being actively maintained. I'm glad I have chosen the other option TBH.

@pagelab Which framework did you go with?