Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

给作者的两点建议,希望kwrt定制平台越来越好 #1983

Open
jpsn123 opened this issue Dec 19, 2024 · 11 comments
Open

给作者的两点建议,希望kwrt定制平台越来越好 #1983

jpsn123 opened this issue Dec 19, 2024 · 11 comments

Comments

@jpsn123
Copy link

jpsn123 commented Dec 19, 2024

作者你好,我是KWRT 3年用户,也赞助你的为爱发电,我希望KWRT越来越好,有两点建议:

  1. KWRT更新策略很激进,这是一个好事,但是一般用户来说是不希望成为OpenWrt官方的测试用户的,所以希望定制选项中能够选择稳定版本
  2. 希望稳定版本的ipk仓库存在时间至少以年为单位,经常因为要安装一个无法下载的ipk包而去重新定制固件

我现在有一个设备是R3S无法使用24.10启动, 一开始以为是KWRT的原因,后来发现其他设备都是正常的,debug后才发现是24.10的使用的上游U-boot模块有问题(alloc space exhausted),但是我又无法刷23.05,因为23.05的KWRT仓库已经不存在了,所以这两天我自己在手动编译23.05,这很浪费时间。

@qin9125
Copy link

qin9125 commented Dec 20, 2024

一样,旧固件我删除了无法回退😔

@Sia7ash
Copy link

Sia7ash commented Dec 23, 2024

Hello author, I am a 3-year KWRT user and also sponsor your Power for Love. I hope KWRT will get better and better. I have two suggestions:

  1. KWRT's update strategy is very aggressive, which is a good thing, but most users do not want to become official OpenWrt testers, so they hope to be able to choose a stable version in the customization options.
  2. I hope that the stable version of the ipk repository will exist for at least a year. I often need to re-customize the firmware because I want to install an ipk package that cannot be downloaded.

I have a device that is R3S and cannot boot with 24.10. At first I thought it was due to KWRT, but later I found that other devices were normal. After debugging, I found that there was a problem with the upstream U-boot module used by 24.10 (alloc space exhausted). However, I cannot flash 23.05 because the KWRT repository for 23.05 no longer exists. So I have been manually compiling 23.05 myself in the past two days, which is a waste of time.

it is not just R3S , I have R2S and R4S and they also not booting with new compile.
I'm just waiting to anybody that reply this massage and tells me that the boot is fixed .

@jpsn123
Copy link
Author

jpsn123 commented Dec 24, 2024

@Sia7ash I also have an R4S device. I just tested it with the latest firmware, and there is no problem with startup. Please check if there is any problem with your SD card.

@1447262390
Copy link

赞同,如果有可以选择稳定版本的话,那真是太好了

@Sia7ash
Copy link

Sia7ash commented Dec 30, 2024

@Sia7ash I also have an R4S device. I just tested it with the latest firmware, and there is no problem with startup. Please check if there is any problem with your SD card.

just test the new release and it boots again but after a moment it restarts
the sd card is ok , it runs previous versions just ok .

@AnChiehChen
Copy link

tplink xdr 6088也是能刷入,启动不了。原因不详;

@youhunluanma
Copy link

题主好,我最近新买的R3S使用本站系统也是无法开机,issue刚才已经详细提了(#2019),但是我在immortalwrt网站下载了目前的24.10.0-rc3版本,下载后可以正常刷入启动开机,下载本站的定制系统或者纯净系统,就是无法启动,我个人依然怀疑是现在的kwrt有问题,毕竟我同一台机器认同样的方法刷imwrt就能开机使用了。我的操作步骤详细已经写在issue#2019了,题主要是有时间的话,可以帮忙试试现在编译的能不能启动,如果题主那边能启动,希望指点指点我的问题出在哪了,我也很喜欢这家的系统,imwrt用不习惯,谢谢!
(我的R3S是2+32G)

@jpsn123
Copy link
Author

jpsn123 commented Jan 13, 2025

@youhunluanma 哎呦 ImmortalWrt 还真开始支持R3S了,刚刚我还不信来着。
KWRT上游是LEAN 无法启动的问题不是KWRT作者的锅,不过我是可以正常启动的,但是R3S最近版本有一个问题,就是LAN和WAN口反了,你看看换一个接口试试,这个也是上游的锅。

@youhunluanma
Copy link

@youhunluanma 哎呦 ImmortalWrt 还真开始支持R3S了,刚刚我还不信来着。 KWRT上游是LEAN 无法启动的问题不是KWRT作者的锅,不过我是可以正常启动的,但是R3S最近版本有一个问题,就是LAN和WAN口反了,你看看换一个接口试试,这个也是上游的锅。

感谢指点,刚才又在本站定制固件测试,我这边的故障依然和#2019一样,交换LAN/WAN 网线以后也依然无法获取IP无法进后台,太可惜了,不知道为什么有的R3S可以有的就不行,按理来说不应该都一样吗,毕竟型号都一样。
另外,在另一个issue(#2007)有另一个朋友clone后编译的固件,在我这边是可以开机的,很奇怪不知道他做了什么

@youhunluanma
Copy link

youhunluanma commented Jan 13, 2025

@youhunluanma 哎呦 ImmortalWrt 还真开始支持R3S了,刚刚我还不信来着。 KWRT上游是LEAN 无法启动的问题不是KWRT作者的锅,不过我是可以正常启动的,但是R3S最近版本有一个问题,就是LAN和WAN口反了,你看看换一个接口试试,这个也是上游的锅。

抱歉我刚才又试了一下,交换WAN/LAN后可以正常开机进后台了。我刚才认为不能进后台原因是他开机太慢了(要开三五分钟,但我只加了不到10个插件且没有Docker,我认为这个速度是不正常的),而且进后台以后正常上网以后,他的LAN/WAN网口依然只亮一个灯、WAN/LAN指示灯(电源灯旁边的)也依然不亮,让我误以为是没有进系统。谢谢!

在我这边出的详细问题可以再看看(#2019),我写在那里面了。再次感谢帮助

@jpsn123
Copy link
Author

jpsn123 commented Jan 15, 2025

@youhunluanma LEAN那边的uboot设备树定义有问题,导致灯对应的不正确,不仅仅是灯,Reset按钮也用不了,但是瑞芯微官方的就是正常的,不过这些都不影响使用,有时间提交一个PR修复一下,最近工作上太忙。爱折腾你也可以学习一下他们的代码,看代码是解决问题的最快方法。

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

6 participants