Ducking seems to work globally

[jabdoa2]

My sound config looks like this:

sound_system:
  tracks:
    voice:
      volume: 0.9
      priority: 2
      simultaneous_sounds: 1
      preload: true
      ducking:
        target: music
        delay: 0
        attack: 0.3 sec
        attenuation: 0.45
        release_point: 0.5 sec
        release: 1.0 sec
    sfx:
      volume: 0.9
      priority: 1
      preload: true
      simultaneous_sounds: 3
    music:
      volume: 0.4
      simultaneous_sounds: 1
  buffer: 2048  # previous value was 512
  frequency: 44100
  channels: 1
  master_volume: 0.8
  enabled: true

Ducking works fine and sounds awesome for all callouts. However, I noticed that it also applies to all my sounds in the sfx track. When I remove ducking for callouts it also disappears for sfx. Any idea why that happens and how to fix it?

[qcapen]

I'm surprised it works at all assigning it at the track level as it is a sound asset property and not associated with any track attributes.

How about assigning it in the default asset settings as follows:

assets:
    sounds:
        default:
            load: preload
        voice:
            load: preload
            track: voice
            ducking:
              target: music
              delay: 0
              attack: 0.3 sec
              attenuation: 0.45
              release_point: 0.5 sec
              release: 1.0 sec

[jabdoa2]

I can try that. I think I added that loading from the track stuff a while back.

[jabdoa2]

I tried the assets config way and it also happens. Dunno why. I verified that the sounds play in the right track (in verbose log).

[qcapen]

Sounds like a real bug. I will write a test to verify and find a fix.

…

On Wed, Mar 14, 2018 at 3:10 PM jabdoa2 ***@***.***> wrote: I tried the assets config way and it also happens. Dunno why. I verified that the sounds play in the right track (in verbose log). — You are receiving this because you were assigned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#315 (comment)>, or mute the thread <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ALxozcShymlEZ5R8fY3UGdkAtv4NL9v3ks5teYc6gaJpZM4SrDUh> .

[qcapen]

Wrote simple test to check sound ducking settings and they are getting set correctly using the assets config method. Now I need to dive in deeper and see if I can replicate the issue.