RFC Discussion 0001: MCP Management Overhaul (Q4 2025 Release)

[AmirTlinov]

Issue Reference: RFC 0001
Source Proposal: #3778
RFC Author: @iMAGRAY

---

Executive Summary

The RFC proposes a full-stack revision of MCP server management to land with the Q4 2025 release. Key outcomes include a guided onboarding experience, a typed registry with transactional guarantees, hardened secret handling, automated health diagnostics, and reversible configuration migrations. The initiative emphasizes security, operability, and extensibility while committing to backward compatibility and clear downgrade paths.

Discussion Themes

• Migration Readiness: Validate the practicality of the rollout plan, prerequisite tooling, cross-functional dependencies, and staffing assumptions across Q4 2025 milestones.
• Secret Management Architecture: Confirm that OS-level keychain integration, rotation workflows, and policy controls satisfy enterprise security, compliance, and audit expectations.
• Operational Safeguards: Surface risks or bottlenecks in automated health checks, rollback orchestration, observability pipelines, and audit logging; recommend mitigations.
• Security and UX Requirements: Capture additional mandates from security, privacy, and UX partners that must be resolved before implementation begins.
• Rollout Strategy: Shape sequencing for preview, beta, and GA phases, including validation frameworks, regression coverage, stakeholder feedback cadence, and success metrics.

Call for Feedback

• Identify integration blockers, technical debt, or ecosystem constraints that could endanger the Q4 2025 target.
• Highlight gaps in migration and rollback coverage, especially for mixed-version fleets or regulated deployments.
• Recommend instrumentation, telemetry, and user-research checkpoints that raise confidence ahead of GA.
• Specify documentation, enablement, or partner-engagement deliverables required to ensure a smooth rollout.

---

Please add detailed findings, actionable suggestions, and open questions below so the team can converge on an execution-ready plan.