`autoapimodule` directive in "manual mode": Imported members are documented

[tony]

Above: Imports visible in documentation with .. autoapimodule directive

Related: #262, #317

Reproduction

https://github.com/vcs-python/libvcs/tree/autoapi-duplicates

Versions

sphinx 5.1.0
sphinx-autoapi 1.9.0

Configuration

conf.py

extensions = [
    "sphinx.ext.napoleon",
    "autoapi.extension",
    "sphinx.ext.autodoc",
    "sphinx.ext.todo",
    "sphinx.ext.intersphinx",
    "myst_parser",
]

# sphinx-autoapi
autoapi_type = "python"
autoapi_dirs = [project_root / "libvcs"]
autoapi_generate_api_docs = False  # when False, use directives

Directions

• git clone https://github.com/vcs-python/libvcs.git --branch autoapi-duplicates
• cd libvcs
• poetry install
• make start_docs
• http://localhost:127.0.0.1
• Examples:
  • projects.git
    localhost: http://localhost:8064/projects/git.html
    markdown source: https://github.com/vcs-python/libvcs/blob/autoapi-duplicates/docs/projects/git.md
    python source: https://github.com/vcs-python/libvcs/blob/autoapi-duplicates/libvcs/projects/git.py
  • cmd.git
    localhost: http://localhost:8064/cmd/git.html
    markdown source: https://github.com/vcs-python/libvcs/blob/autoapi-duplicates/docs/cmd/git.md
    python source: https://github.com/vcs-python/libvcs/blob/autoapi-duplicates/libvcs/cmd/git.py
  • _internal.run
    localhost: http://localhost:8064/internals/run.html, e.g. StrOrBytesPath
    markdown source: https://github.com/vcs-python/libvcs/blob/autoapi-duplicates/docs/internals/run.md
    python source: https://github.com/vcs-python/libvcs/blob/autoapi-duplicates/libvcs/_internal/run.py
• Workarounds to scope:
  • __all__ does not work: projects.hg
    localhost: http://localhost:8064/projects/hg.html
    markdown source: https://github.com/vcs-python/libvcs/blob/autoapi-duplicates/docs/projects/hg.md
    python source: https://github.com/vcs-python/libvcs/blob/autoapi-duplicates/libvcs/projects/hg.py

Workaround

Workaround ATM exclude-members for each usage:

.. autoapimodule:: libvcs.projects.git
   :members:
   :show-inheritance:
   :undoc-members:
   :exclude-members: BaseProject, StrOrBytesPath, StrPath

Discussion

• Any better workarounds?
• Is this a bug or expected behavior?
• Could my package structure be playing a role?
• Anyone else experiencing this? Ideas / workarounds?

[tony]

Updated example from sphinx 5.0 to 5.1, autoapi 1.8.0 -> 1.9.0

[ashb]

Not sure if this is the same issue, related or something else entirely, but the autoapi-skip-member event also doesn't seem to fire for things documented by autoapimodule directives.