Make HTML report look like it was before

[SNBogdanov]

Reqnroll Version

3.3.1

Which test runner are you using?

MSTest

Test Runner Version Number

4.0.2

.NET Implementation

.NET Framework 4.8

Test Execution Method

Visual Studio Test Explorer

Content of reqnroll.json configuration file

{
  "$schema": "https://schemas.reqnroll.net/reqnroll-config-latest.json",

  "bindingAssemblies": [
  ],
  "runtime": { "stopAtFirstError": true },
  "generator": {
    "allowDebugGeneratedFiles": false,
    "allowRowTests": true
  }
}

Issue Description

I used reqnroll v 3.2.1 and it was Ok, but with wrong detection of number in HTML report so I opened issue
#835
Thi issue was closed in 3.3.1
But after updating reqnroll to v 3.3.1 my report becomes unreadable.
Before I had managed to skip test with AssertInconclusiveException without exception text in report. Also I had correct scenario outline with all success, failed and not run scenarios. Now I don't have it at all. So report became different and completely unusable. Is it possible to configure html behaviour by setting some parameters or I need to rollback version back to 3.2.1

Arena_Autotest_ARN-T5688_Regress_20260112152754.html

Arena_Autotest_ARN-T5688_Regress_20260112153051.html

Steps to Reproduce

No steps, just check report

Link to Repro Project

No response

[304NotModified]

But after updating reqnroll to v 3.3.1 my report becomes unreadable.

Please be more clear of the issues and the expectations. Yes we could see changes, but of course be could also see other issues that are/aren't important.

[SNBogdanov]

But after updating reqnroll to v 3.3.1 my report becomes unreadable.

Please be more clear of the issues and the expectations. Yes we could see changes, but of course be could also see other issues that are/aren't important.

My expectation is that I receive almost same report as before with only change is left align of scenarios.
I don't want to see hooks at all (before and after )
I don't want to see AssertInconclusiveException.
PS:
It's good that I was able to revert to v 3.2.1 and my report is back to normal (99%)
PPS:
The problem is in Cucumber.HtmlFormatter v 22.1.0. This version is not good for me

[gasparnagy]

But after updating reqnroll to v 3.3.1 my report becomes unreadable.

Please be more clear of the issues and the expectations. Yes we could see changes, but of course be could also see other issues that are/aren't important.

My expectation is that I receive almost same report as before with only change is left align of scenarios. I don't want to see hooks at all (before and after ) I don't want to see AssertInconclusiveException. PS: It's good that I was able to revert to v 3.2.1 and my report is back to normal (99%) PPS: The problem is in Cucumber.HtmlFormatter v 22.1.0. This version is not good for me

Here are my thoughts.

1. The AssertInconclusiveException in your second linked sample seems to be wrong, indeed. We will need to check that. @clrudolphi What do you think?

2. For the hooks: I think in long term, we could introduce a setting to enable/disable hooks in the HTML document. I think this might be an interesting feature request. Please create a separate feature request for this to https://github.com/orgs/reqnroll/discussions/categories/ideas

3. In general, you can make customized HTML report (also with different HtmlFormatter versions) based on the sample project here: https://github.com/reqnroll/Reqnroll.ExploratoryTestProjects/tree/main/ReqnrollFormatters/ReqnrollFormatters.CustomizedHtml

[SNBogdanov]

3. In general, you can make customized HTML report (also with different HtmlFormatter versions) based on the sample project here: https://github.com/reqnroll/Reqnroll.ExploratoryTestProjects/tree/main/ReqnrollFormatters/ReqnrollFormatters.CustomizedHtml

This could be usefull in future when it will become fully implemented with samples how to build custom report, but currently it is absollutly unusable.
Also for future custom reports it will be nice to have sample projects with possibility to see result before jumping into deep water of programming of such report.

[clrudolphi]

@SNBogdanov please reconfirm - are you on net9 or Framework 4.8? The description of the issue indicates .net 9, but the html report indicates it is running under .NET Framework 4.8.

[SNBogdanov]

@SNBogdanov please reconfirm - are you on net9 or Framework 4.8? The description of the issue indicates .net 9, but the html report indicates it is running under .NET Framework 4.8.

Sorry. I need .NET Framework 4.8

[clrudolphi]

PPS: The problem is in Cucumber.HtmlFormatter v 22.1.0. This version is not good for me

Why do you call out this particular version of HtmlFormatter? Elsewhere you report using Reqnroll v3.3.1 (and the screenshot of the html report confirms that). If so, that means you are using HtmlFormatter v22.2.0.

I want to ensure I'm looking at the right combination of dependencies.

[SNBogdanov]

I installed reqnrall 3.3.1 with 22.3 formatter. And received problem. After i reverted to 3.2.1 and got 22.0 formatter. Everything was ok. I upgraded only formatter to see where is the problem. It started with 22.1.0

[gasparnagy]

3. In general, you can make customized HTML report (also with different HtmlFormatter versions) based on the sample project here: https://github.com/reqnroll/Reqnroll.ExploratoryTestProjects/tree/main/ReqnrollFormatters/ReqnrollFormatters.CustomizedHtml

This could be usefull in future when it will become fully implemented with samples how to build custom report, but currently it is absollutly unusable. Also for future custom reports it will be nice to have sample projects with possibility to see result before jumping into deep water of programming of such report.

Could you please check the linked sample project and try if you can build a custom one based on that? Maybe we can make a good documentation page out of your findings.