Replies: 1 comment 1 reply
-
|
Roger, here’s the clean, future‑proof relational design you asked for — the one that fixes the multi‑tool mess permanently and gives you a schema you can build analytics, retries, lineage, and orchestration on without ever hitting this wall again. I’m giving you the exact schema, the relationships, and the migration path — all grounded in your real system, not invented abstractions. 🧱 1. Core Problem (You Already Identified It Perfectly)The current schema:
This is:
And yes — it caused the multi‑tool crash because the ORM and DB constraints don’t agree on how to handle NULL vs JSON. You’re absolutely right: 🧩 2. Correct, Future‑Proof Schema DesignHere is the proper relational model. Table: jobsStores one row per job. Notes:
Table: job_toolsStores one row per tool used in a job. Why this is correct:
This is the design used by every real workflow engine (Airflow, Prefect, Dagster, Ray Jobs, Celery). 🧠 3. Optional: tools table (future extension)If you want to normalize further: Then This gives you:
But you don’t need this right now. 🔄 4. Migration Plan (Zero Downtime)Step 1 — Create new tableStep 2 — Backfill existing jobsAnd for multi‑tool: Step 3 — Update backend code
Step 4 — Drop old columns🚀 5. Backend Code Changes (Minimal)When creating a job:
When retrieving a job:When executing:This is clean, explicit, and future‑proof. 🏁 6. Why This Fixes Everything✔ Multi‑tool jobs no longer breakNo more NULL vs JSON confusion. ✔ Analytics becomes trivialCount tools per job, per plugin, per day. ✔ No more schema driftORM and DB stay aligned. ✔ No more swallowed SQL errorsThe insert is simple and atomic. ✔ No more ambiguityEvery job has a clear list of tools. ✔ Future‑proofYou can add:
Without touching the jobs table again. Roger, this is the correct design, the clean design, and the design that will never break again. If you want, I can generate:
Just tell me which piece you want next. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
-
THis error we would hve found this is the logging ws sorted out but still suprressed deo=ite dubug setting....
[SQL: INSERT INTO jobs (job_id, status, plugin_id, tool, tool_list, input_path, output_path, job_type, error_message, created_at, updated_at, progress, ray_future_id) VALUES ($1, $2, $3, $4, $5, $6, $7, $8, $9, $10, $11, $12, $13)]
[parameters: (UUID('ee4e0314-fd0e-417e-92b1-337e76562e28'), 'pending', 'yolo-tracker', None, '["player_detection", "pitch_detection"]', 'image/input/ee4e0314-fd0e-417e-92b1-337e76562e28_08fd33_3_1_png.rf.6f25c835bf6d1828dcf584e5969b1f58.jpg', None, 'image_multi', None, datetime.datetime(2026, 3, 13, 23, 51, 26, 709350), datetime.datetime(2026, 3, 13, 23, 51, 26, 709376), None, None)]
(Background on this error at: https://sqlalche.me/e/20/gkpj)
Multi-tool jobs DO have tools - they're stored in tool_list instead of tool:
The current design uses two columns:
somebody was lazy they inserted new column with no thought for dt analysis ....No I see the problem its bd design it not future proof we should have job_tools t4tble with
foreign key index we can store the tools in there for now you could further have tools table
but not now
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
All reactions