Allow JuliaFormatter v2

[ChrisRackauckas]

CompatHelper seems to be disabled here?

[simonschoelly]

CompatHelper seems to be disabled here?

Are you sure? I do admit that I haven't seen any PR from CompatHelper in a while but it looks like the workflow still run:

Perhaps something is outdated.

[simonschoelly]

From the logs it looks like CompatHelper does not check [extras].

 ┌ Error: The dependency was not found in any of the registries
│   dep.package.name = "SharedArrays"
│   dep = CompatHelper.DepInfo(CompatHelper.Package("SharedArrays", Base.UUID("1a1011a3-84de-559e-8e89-a11a2f7dc383")), nothing, nothing, nothing)
└ @ CompatHelper ~/.julia/packages/CompatHelper/K9Pyo/src/utilities/new_versions.jl:198
┌ Info: latest_version in version_spec
│   dep.latest_version = v"0.9.4"
│   dep.version_spec = VersionSpec("0.9")
│   dep.package.name = "SimpleTraits"
└   dep = CompatHelper.DepInfo(CompatHelper.Package("SimpleTraits", Base.UUID("699a6c99-e7fa-54fc-8d76-47d257e15c1d")), v"0.9.4", VersionSpec("0.9"), "0.9")
┌ Info: latest_version in version_spec
│   dep.latest_version = v"1.11.1"
│   dep.version_spec = VersionSpec("1")
│   dep.package.name = "Statistics"
└   dep = CompatHelper.DepInfo(CompatHelper.Package("Statistics", Base.UUID("10745b16-79ce-11e8-11f9-7d13ad32a3b2")), v"1.11.1", VersionSpec("1"), "1")
┌ Error: The dependency was not found in any of the registries
│   dep.package.name = "SparseArrays"
│   dep = CompatHelper.DepInfo(CompatHelper.Package("SparseArrays", Base.UUID("2f01184e-e22b-5df5-ae63-d93ebab69eaf")), nothing, nothing, nothing)
└ @ CompatHelper ~/.julia/packages/CompatHelper/K9Pyo/src/utilities/new_versions.jl:198
┌ Info: latest_version in version_spec
│   dep.latest_version = v"0.18.22"
│   dep.version_spec = VersionSpec("0.17 - 0.18")
│   dep.package.name = "DataStructures"
└   dep = CompatHelper.DepInfo(CompatHelper.Package("DataStructures", Base.UUID("864edb3b-99cc-5e75-8d2d-829cb0a9cfe8")), v"0.18.22", VersionSpec("0.17 - 0.18"), "0.17, 0.18")
┌ Error: The dependency was not found in any of the registries
│   dep.package.name = "Distributed"
│   dep = CompatHelper.DepInfo(CompatHelper.Package("Distributed", Base.UUID("8ba89e20-285c-5b6f-9357-94700520ee1b")), nothing, nothing, nothing)
└ @ CompatHelper ~/.julia/packages/CompatHelper/K9Pyo/src/utilities/new_versions.jl:198
┌ Info: latest_version in version_spec
│   dep.latest_version = v"0.1.5"
│   dep.version_spec = VersionSpec("0.1.3 - 0.1")
│   dep.package.name = "Inflate"
└   dep = CompatHelper.DepInfo(CompatHelper.Package("Inflate", Base.UUID("d25df0c9-e2be-5dd7-82c8-3ad0b3e990b9")), v"0.1.5", VersionSpec("0.1.3 - 0.1"), "0.1.3")
┌ Info: latest_version in version_spec
│   dep.latest_version = v"0.4.0"
│   dep.version_spec = VersionSpec("0.4")
│   dep.package.name = "ArnoldiMethod"
└   dep = CompatHelper.DepInfo(CompatHelper.Package("ArnoldiMethod", Base.UUID("ec485272-7323-5ecc-a04f-4719b315124d")), v"0.4.0", VersionSpec("0.4"), "0.4")
┌ Error: The dependency was not found in any of the registries
│   dep.package.name = "LinearAlgebra"
│   dep = CompatHelper.DepInfo(CompatHelper.Package("LinearAlgebra", Base.UUID("37e2e46d-f89d-539d-b4ee-838fcccc9c8e")), nothing, nothing, nothing)
└ @ CompatHelper ~/.julia/packages/CompatHelper/K9Pyo/src/utilities/new_versions.jl:198
┌ Error: The dependency was not found in any of the registries
│   dep.package.name = "Random"
│   dep = CompatHelper.DepInfo(CompatHelper.Package("Random", Base.UUID("9a3f8284-a2c9-5f02-9a11-845980a1fd5c")), nothing, nothing, nothing)
└ @ CompatHelper ~/.julia/packages/CompatHelper/K9Pyo/src/utilities/new_versions.jl:198

[simonschoelly]

Apparently there is an open PR JuliaRegistries/CompatHelper.jl#502 related to also check test dependencies.

[Krastanov]

@simonschoelly , for my packages I have switched away from using extras and rather using a sub Project.toml for the tests. I believe that started being supported somewhere around the julia 1.3ish era. If you are ok with it, I can go ahead and split the Project.toml's extras into a test/Project.toml.

This would have "accidentally" fixed the current issue, as usually there are no compat bounds for test/Project.toml.

[Krastanov]

test/Project.toml is from the Julia 1.2 era: https://pkgdocs.julialang.org/v1/creating-packages/#Alternative-approach:-test/Project.toml-file-test-specific-dependencies

[simonschoelly]

@simonschoelly , for my packages I have switched away from using extras and rather using a sub Project.toml for the tests. I believe that started being supported somewhere around the julia 1.3ish era. If you are ok with it, I can go ahead and split the Project.toml's extras into a test/Project.toml.

This would have "accidentally" fixed the current issue, as usually there are no compat bounds for test/Project.toml.

I don't have an opinion on that - if you think we should try that out, why not?

Although I am not sure that JuliaFormatter is purely for testing - some people might also use it as a precommit hook for git - then they would have to activate the testing environment?

[ChrisRackauckas]

All of this is all well and good, but in the meantime, could we unblock JuliaFormatter v2 from downstream? The only test failure here is formatter error, want me to reformat the whole package or someone else?

[simonschoelly]

I am not sure how I can add something to your PR - so the changes are here: #435

[Krastanov]

check #436 for potentially a simpler and quicker alternative