Skip to content

Security: Neeeophytee/ai-watermarks-reality-check

Security

SECURITY.md

Security policy

Scope

These skills are read-only analyzers. They parse untrusted files and untrusted verifier output, so the security surface is parsing and subprocess handling.

Security-relevant reports include:

  • A crafted asset that causes a crash, hang, unbounded memory use, or path escape.
  • A crafted asset or verifier output that produces a conclusive result it should not — most importantly ABSENT, NOT_DETECTED, VALID, or TRUSTED.
  • Any path where an analyzer writes to, moves, or deletes an input.
  • Value leakage: audit-metadata-privacy printing raw metadata values.

Reports about a vendor's watermark or about C2PA itself belong upstream, not here.

Reporting

Open a private security advisory through the repository's GitHub Security tab. Please include the input that triggers the behaviour, or a script that generates it, plus the tool, the version, and the observed and expected states.

We aim to acknowledge within 7 days. This is a small volunteer project with no paid on-call rotation; please do not expect a same-day response.

The rule, stated once

The distinction is whether the tool failed closed:

Situation Classification
A carrier is not implemented and the tool returns UNKNOWN with a reason Coverage gap. Open a normal issue.
A carrier is not implemented, or a scan was incomplete, and the tool returns ABSENT, NOT_DETECTED, VALID, TRUSTED, or exit 0 Fail-closed defect. Report privately as security-relevant.

An unjustified conclusive result is the most serious class of defect in this project, because a downstream reader will act on it. An honest UNKNOWN is never a vulnerability, however incomplete the coverage behind it.

What is not a vulnerability

  • The inability to detect a keyed vendor watermark. That is by construction.
  • c2patool defects. Report those to the ContentAuth project.

Supported versions

The most recent release only. There is no long-term support branch.

There aren't any published security advisories