Skip to content

Conversation

@monen17
Copy link

@monen17 monen17 commented Jul 25, 2025

The existing module conflicts with a new module named exactly l10n_it_riba in Odoo Enterprise.

We are implementing the migration in OCA/l10n-italy#4856, I will set this as ready for review when the linked PR is merged.

The existing module conflicts with a new module named exactly l10n_it_riba in Odoo Enterprise
@MiquelRForgeFlow MiquelRForgeFlow added this to the 16.0 milestone Jul 25, 2025
@peregrine-2024
Copy link

Change Risk Summary

This Pull Request introduces changes by renaming a module from l10n_it_ricevute_bancarie to l10n_it_riba_oca. This renaming poses various risks such as potential misconfiguration, data migration issues, dependency mismatches, and integration problems. The change could affect the compatibility and functionality of any systems relying on the old module name unless they are updated to reflect this change.

Critical Change Issues

  1. Misconfiguration Risk: The module name change requires updates across all configurations and references, and failure to do so can lead to broken references elsewhere in the codebase.
  2. Data Migration Risk: Existing data migration scripts or handlers linked to the old module name may fail or cause data inconsistencies if not adapted to accommodate the new name.
  3. Dependency Issues: The new module name might bring about unresolved dependencies if specific to the old module structure.

Testing Workflows

  1. Module Load and Dependencies: Ensure the renamed module loads correctly, and all necessary dependencies are intact.
  2. Backward Compatibility: Test all existing functionalities dependent on the old module name to verify that they work seamlessly with the new name.
  3. Data Access and Integrity: Validate that data associated with the original module is still accessible and manipulatable through the renamed module.
  4. Integration Tests: Conduct comprehensive integration testing to ensure that the renamed module functions correctly with all connected modules and services.

Change Risk Rating

3 - Medium Risk: The risk level is set to medium due to the moderate changes involving key structural components of the codebase. Renaming a module carries inherent integration and data management challenges that require careful testing. These changes affect core pathways in the code, and any oversight could cascade into broader system issues.

Final Recommendation

GO: The changes introduce a medium level of risk due to their ability to affect integration and data stability. However, with thorough testing focused on critical areas such as module loading, backward compatibility, data access, and conducting full integration tests, these risks can be mitigated. Deployment can proceed, provided these areas are diligently tested and verified.

@peregrine-2024
Copy link

Change Risk Summary

The Pull Request introduces a significant change through the renaming of a module from l10n_it_ricevute_bancarie to l10n_it_riba_oca. This change affects not only the direct references but also impacts dependencies, data handling, and requires updates in integration processes. The primary risk is the possibility of system breakage due to unresolved references, mismanaged data migrations, and outdated documentation or integration references.

Critical Change Issues

  1. Potential Module Breakage: The renaming could lead to failures if the old module name is still referenced anywhere in the system.
  2. Data Migration Concerns: There is a risk of data inconsistency or loss if migration scripts do not manage the transition of data and configurations from the old module name to the new one.
  3. Integration Disruptions: Dependencies on the old module name by other modules or external integrations may not function correctly if not properly updated.

Testing Workflows

  1. Module Dependency Trees: Verify that l10n_it_riba_oca integrates correctly with dependent or custom modules that originally referenced l10n_it_ricevute_bancarie.
  2. Data Validation: Ensure all data and settings are accurately retained and accessible following the module rename.
  3. Upgrade Paths: Test the upgrade process from systems using l10n_it_ricevute_bancarie to l10n_it_riba_oca, confirming that migration scripts handle all necessary transitions effectively.

Change Risk Rating

3 - Medium Risk: The renaming represents a moderate change that necessitates rigorous testing. The risk derives mainly from the potential for disruptions in module dependencies, data consistency, and integration processes. However, if managed well with sufficient testing and updated references, these risks can be mitigated.

Final Recommendation

GO: While the changes introduce a medium level of risk, these can be mitigated with comprehensive testing to ensure all references and dependencies are correctly updated. The change is manageable and, with proper preparation and validation, can be deployed confidently. It is recommended that all testing recommendations be rigorously followed to maintain system integrity.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants