Skip to content
Open
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
Show all changes
20 commits
Select commit Hold shift + click to select a range
5ebc334
Rename merged.json to merged.json
Sliicy Jun 18, 2023
7d88e82
Rename Conversion According to Halakhah - What Is It Judaism 23 Fall …
Sliicy Jun 18, 2023
e7df744
Rename Conversion According to Halakhah - What Is It Judaism 23 Fall …
Sliicy Jun 18, 2023
2f9001a
Rename merged.json to merged.json
Sliicy Jun 18, 2023
ba80c4a
Rename Conversion According to Halakhah - What Is It Judaism 23 Fall …
Sliicy Jun 18, 2023
da79366
Rename merged.json to merged.json
Sliicy Jun 18, 2023
dceb02a
Rename merged.txt to merged.txt
Sliicy Jun 18, 2023
3cb749c
Rename Conversion According to Halakhah - What Is It Judaism 23 Fall …
Sliicy Jun 18, 2023
17f7b30
Update Conversion_"According_to_Halakhah";_What_Is_It.json
Sliicy Jun 18, 2023
2e4bb0f
Update merged.json
Sliicy Jun 18, 2023
5adc50d
Update Conversion According to Halakhah - What Is It Judaism 23 Fall …
Sliicy Jun 18, 2023
f9c23db
Update Conversion According to Halakhah - What Is It Judaism 23 Fall …
Sliicy Jun 18, 2023
baa0476
Update merged.txt
Sliicy Jun 18, 2023
d642939
Update merged.json
Sliicy Jun 18, 2023
cd8aa8e
Update Conversion According to Halakhah - What Is It Judaism 23 Fall …
Sliicy Jun 18, 2023
4b33aff
Update Conversion According to Halakhah - What Is It Judaism 23 Fall …
Sliicy Jun 18, 2023
f8ba20f
Update merged.json
Sliicy Jun 18, 2023
ea6821c
Update Conversion According to Halakhah - What Is It Judaism 23 Fall …
Sliicy Jun 18, 2023
31d7dcd
Rename Conversion_"According_to_Halakhah";_What_Is_It.json to Convers…
Sliicy Jun 18, 2023
bfdea41
Fixed 'According to Halakhah' in table of contents
Sliicy Jun 19, 2023
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -26,5 +26,5 @@
"3_Chapter, 9_Paragraph": "__________<br><small>ELIEZER BERKOVITS</small> <i>is chairman of the philosophy department of the Hebrew Theological College, Skokie, Illinois</i>."
},
"meta": "Chapter-Paragraph",
"work": "Conversion \"According to Halakhah\"; What Is It"
}
"work": "Conversion 'According to Halakhah'; What Is It"
}
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -26,5 +26,5 @@
"3_Chapter, 9_Paragraph": "__________<br><small>ELIEZER BERKOVITS</small> <i>is chairman of the philosophy department of the Hebrew Theological College, Skokie, Illinois</i>."
},
"meta": "Chapter-Paragraph",
"work": "Conversion \"According to Halakhah\"; What Is It"
}
"work": "Conversion 'According to Halakhah'; What Is It"
}
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -34,5 +34,5 @@
}
},
"meta": "Chapter-Paragraph",
"work": "Conversion \"According to Halakhah\"; What Is It"
}
"work": "Conversion 'According to Halakhah'; What Is It"
}
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -34,5 +34,5 @@
}
},
"meta": "Chapter-Paragraph",
"work": "Conversion \"According to Halakhah\"; What Is It"
}
"work": "Conversion 'According to Halakhah'; What Is It"
}
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -1,8 +1,8 @@
{
"language": "en",
"title": "Conversion \"According to Halakhah\"; What Is It",
"title": "Conversion 'According to Halakhah'; What Is It",
"versionSource": "https://www.nli.org.il/he/journals/NNL_ALEPH997007800684005171/NLI",
"versionTitle": "Conversion \"According to Halakhah\" - What Is It: Judaism 23 (Fall 1974): 467-78",
"versionTitle": "Conversion 'According to Halakhah' - What Is It: Judaism 23 (Fall 1974): 467-78",
"status": "locked",
"license": "CC-BY-NC",
"digitizedBySefaria": true,
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -52,4 +52,4 @@
"Chapter",
"Paragraph"
]
}
}
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -1,8 +1,8 @@
{
"title": "Conversion \"According to Halakhah\"; What Is It",
"title": "Conversion 'According to Halakhah'; What Is It",
"language": "en",
"versionTitle": "merged",
"versionSource": "https://www.sefaria.org/Conversion_\"According_to_Halakhah\";_What_Is_It",
"versionSource": "https://www.sefaria.org/Conversion_'According_to_Halakhah';_What_Is_It",
"text": [
[
"<small>OUR CONCERN HERE IS NOT WITH THE POLITICAL</small> issues, struggles, and bickerings that are usually associated with the title of this essay. Strictly speaking, our chief interest here is not even with the question of conversion. What we intend to discuss is the meaning of the term, <i>al pi halakhah</i>, according to <i>halakhah</i>. We shall use the problem of conversion in the State of Israel, which has embroiled us so long and generated so much bitterness among Jews, as an example to illustrate the fundamental problem of halakhah in our days.",
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -39,7 +39,7 @@
],
"versions": [
[
"Conversion \"According to Halakhah\" - What Is It: Judaism 23 (Fall 1974): 467-78",
"Conversion 'According to Halakhah' - What Is It: Judaism 23 (Fall 1974): 467-78",
"https://www.nli.org.il/he/journals/NNL_ALEPH997007800684005171/NLI"
]
],
Expand All @@ -53,4 +53,4 @@
"Chapter",
"Paragraph"
]
}
}
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -1,5 +1,5 @@
{
"title": "Conversion \"According to Halakhah\"; What Is It",
"title": "Conversion 'According to Halakhah'; What Is It",
"categories": [
"Jewish Thought",
"Modern",
Expand All @@ -23,18 +23,18 @@
"text": "גיור 'כהלכתו' - מהו?"
},
{
"text": "Conversion \"According to Halakhah\"; What Is It",
"text": "Conversion 'According to Halakhah'; What Is It",
"lang": "en",
"primary": true
}
],
"title": "Conversion \"According to Halakhah\"; What Is It",
"title": "Conversion 'According to Halakhah'; What Is It",
"heTitle": "גיור 'כהלכתו' - מהו?",
"heSectionNames": [
"פרק",
"פסקה"
],
"key": "Conversion \"According to Halakhah\"; What Is It"
"key": "Conversion 'According to Halakhah'; What Is It"
},
"authors": [
{
Expand All @@ -53,7 +53,7 @@
"era": "CO",
"heTitle": "גיור 'כהלכתו' - מהו?",
"titleVariants": [
"Conversion \"According to Halakhah\"; What Is It"
"Conversion 'According to Halakhah'; What Is It"
],
"heTitleVariants": [
"גיור 'כהלכתו' - מהו?"
Expand All @@ -76,4 +76,4 @@
"en": "Skokie, Illinois",
"he": "סקוקי"
}
}
}
2 changes: 1 addition & 1 deletion table_of_contents.json
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -114081,7 +114081,7 @@
"enShortDesc": "Argument for Jewish unity as a critical variable in deciding how to formulate Orthodox conversion policy.",
"heShortDesc": "",
"heTitle": "גיור 'כהלכתו' - מהו?",
"title": "Conversion \"According to Halakhah\"; What Is It"
"title": "Conversion 'According to Halakhah'; What Is It"
},
{
"categories": [
Expand Down
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -1,9 +1,9 @@
Conversion "According to Halakhah"; What Is It
Conversion 'According to Halakhah'; What Is It
גיור 'כהלכתו' - מהו?
Conversion "According to Halakhah" - What Is It: Judaism 23 (Fall 1974): 467-78
Conversion 'According to Halakhah' - What Is It: Judaism 23 (Fall 1974): 467-78
https://www.nli.org.il/he/journals/NNL_ALEPH997007800684005171/NLI

Conversion "According to Halakhah"; What Is It
Conversion 'According to Halakhah'; What Is It



Expand Down Expand Up @@ -41,4 +41,4 @@ It was part of the spiritual tragedy of the <i>Galut</i> that exactly what halak
Today, however, we are faced with unprecedented new challenges and problems, problems of a true halakhic nature, which require solutions in the true halakhic spirit. This is true in the free societies in which Jews live, but it is compellingly manifest in the State of Israel. When some leading rabbinical authorities there maintain that halakhah can solve all of the problems that may be raised for Judaism in a modern state they are right and they are wrong. They are right, for halakhah in its original strength could solve all such problems. Yet, they are wrong. Halakhah, in its present strait-jacketed state, cannot fulfill that function.
This is certainly no plea for reform. We believe that many of our inherited moulds are leaking and cannot meaningfully contain the life that has fallen to the lot of our generation. What is needed, first of all, is to retrace our steps. To return to the original halakhah, to rediscover it, and, having rediscovered it, to restore it to its original function. If only the problem were thoroughly understood, it would liberate us from the stultifying burden of this “Karaite halakhah.” We would then see that in this generation we have been called upon, as it were, by another <i>bat kol</i> to accept the responsibility to make use of whatever is still left of the Oral Torah in its textual solidification. It would be the beginning that would lead us back to the original source and strength of halakhah. It would be the beginning of its restoration to its original vitality and dignity, for the sake of which God concluded this covenant of mutuality with Israel. What is needed is not less study of Torah, but better study of Torah. What is needed is at least one Talmud research institute that would be dedicated to this task of rediscovery of halakhah and—at first—its intellectual restoration. What is needed is not less dedication to halakhah, but more faith in halakhah. Where there is greater faith, greater boldness is justified.
As in the past, because it was a time to act for God, shackles had to be placed on the Oral Torah in violation of God’s command, so now the hour has come when the need to act for God places upon us the responsibility to free the Oral Torah from its shackles in obedience to God’s original command. There are risks involved in such an undertaking. Because of it we need, not less, but more <i>yi’rat shammayim</i> (fear of God). But, possibly, most of all, we need to join much more <i>ahavat Yisrael</i> to our <i>ahavat ha-torah</i>, by far more love of all Israel to illuminate our love of Torah. And pray to God for His guidance.
__________<br><small>ELIEZER BERKOVITS</small> <i>is chairman of the philosophy department of the Hebrew Theological College, Skokie, Illinois</i>.
__________<br><small>ELIEZER BERKOVITS</small> <i>is chairman of the philosophy department of the Hebrew Theological College, Skokie, Illinois</i>.
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -1,12 +1,12 @@
Conversion "According to Halakhah"; What Is It
Conversion 'According to Halakhah'; What Is It
גיור 'כהלכתו' - מהו?
merged
https://www.sefaria.org/Conversion_"According_to_Halakhah";_What_Is_It
https://www.sefaria.org/Conversion_'According_to_Halakhah';_What_Is_It
This file contains merged sections from the following text versions:
-Conversion "According to Halakhah" - What Is It: Judaism 23 (Fall 1974): 467-78
-Conversion 'According to Halakhah' - What Is It: Judaism 23 (Fall 1974): 467-78
-https://www.nli.org.il/he/journals/NNL_ALEPH997007800684005171/NLI

Conversion "According to Halakhah"; What Is It
Conversion 'According to Halakhah'; What Is It



Expand Down Expand Up @@ -44,4 +44,4 @@ It was part of the spiritual tragedy of the <i>Galut</i> that exactly what halak
Today, however, we are faced with unprecedented new challenges and problems, problems of a true halakhic nature, which require solutions in the true halakhic spirit. This is true in the free societies in which Jews live, but it is compellingly manifest in the State of Israel. When some leading rabbinical authorities there maintain that halakhah can solve all of the problems that may be raised for Judaism in a modern state they are right and they are wrong. They are right, for halakhah in its original strength could solve all such problems. Yet, they are wrong. Halakhah, in its present strait-jacketed state, cannot fulfill that function.
This is certainly no plea for reform. We believe that many of our inherited moulds are leaking and cannot meaningfully contain the life that has fallen to the lot of our generation. What is needed, first of all, is to retrace our steps. To return to the original halakhah, to rediscover it, and, having rediscovered it, to restore it to its original function. If only the problem were thoroughly understood, it would liberate us from the stultifying burden of this “Karaite halakhah.” We would then see that in this generation we have been called upon, as it were, by another <i>bat kol</i> to accept the responsibility to make use of whatever is still left of the Oral Torah in its textual solidification. It would be the beginning that would lead us back to the original source and strength of halakhah. It would be the beginning of its restoration to its original vitality and dignity, for the sake of which God concluded this covenant of mutuality with Israel. What is needed is not less study of Torah, but better study of Torah. What is needed is at least one Talmud research institute that would be dedicated to this task of rediscovery of halakhah and—at first—its intellectual restoration. What is needed is not less dedication to halakhah, but more faith in halakhah. Where there is greater faith, greater boldness is justified.
As in the past, because it was a time to act for God, shackles had to be placed on the Oral Torah in violation of God’s command, so now the hour has come when the need to act for God places upon us the responsibility to free the Oral Torah from its shackles in obedience to God’s original command. There are risks involved in such an undertaking. Because of it we need, not less, but more <i>yi’rat shammayim</i> (fear of God). But, possibly, most of all, we need to join much more <i>ahavat Yisrael</i> to our <i>ahavat ha-torah</i>, by far more love of all Israel to illuminate our love of Torah. And pray to God for His guidance.
__________<br><small>ELIEZER BERKOVITS</small> <i>is chairman of the philosophy department of the Hebrew Theological College, Skokie, Illinois</i>.
__________<br><small>ELIEZER BERKOVITS</small> <i>is chairman of the philosophy department of the Hebrew Theological College, Skokie, Illinois</i>.