Track daily model version updates - #1644
Conversation
|
Adversarial review result: request changes. GitHub would not let this account submit a formal request-changes review because the authenticated app is the PR author, so I am posting the blocking review as a PR comment. Blocking findings
QA / verification
Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
|
Review decision: changes required. I could not submit this as a formal request-changes review because GitHub rejected it for this actor with: The main issue is provenance: every new accepted claim points at a new Blockers:
Major issues:
QA/verification:
Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
|
Thanks for the catalog update. I’m requesting changes because the new accepted claims leave dangling graph references and do not update the canonical topology the linked issues ask for. Blockers
Majors
QAI dispatched QA via Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Live-stack QAResult: not passed — the dispatched live-stack run was still Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31061166580 Current job status
Matrix tested
Overall verdict: not passed yet. No live-stack failure was observed in the polling window, but |
Live-stack QAResult: blocked / timed out The adversarial live-stack QA run was dispatched, but the Babysitter wait step timed out after 20 minutes while the GitHub Actions run was still Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31061264473 Current job state
Matrix tested
Overall verdict: not passed yet. No live-stack matrix job conclusions were available before timeout; re-check the Actions run for final pass/fail. |
Live-stack QAResult: not passed yet - workflow is still queued/running after the 20 minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31061163727
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31pro","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"anthropic-sonnet46","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31pro","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"}
]Verdict: not passed yet. The selected adversarial live-stack QA run dispatched successfully, Build All passed, and the live-stack matrix jobs are pending. |
Live-stack QAResult: timeout waiting for completion. The live-stack workflow was still in progress when the 20-minute QA polling window elapsed. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31061263806 Current job status
Focused adversarial matrix
Reasoning: PR #1644 changes Atlas graph catalog claim YAML for model/provider version evidence. This matrix covers a Gemini 3.1 Pro Preview catalog-consuming path, a Foundry/OpenAI baseline, and BP predefined/create paths without dispatching the full cross-product. |
Live-stack QAResult: timed out / pending. The live-stack workflow was dispatched for adversarial QA, but the predefined 20-minute poll window expired before the scenario jobs completed. Build setup passed; live-stack scenario jobs are still queued. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31061258869 Matrix tested
Current job status
Overall verdict: not passed yet because the scenario jobs did not complete within the process timeout. No scenario failure was observed before timeout. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete. The adversarial QA workflow was dispatched, but the Babysitter wait step timed out after 20 polling attempts while the GitHub Actions run was still Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31061279274
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31pro","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true},
{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31pro","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true},
{"agent":"claude","model":"anthropic-sonnet46","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true},
{"agent":"codex","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"bridged-interactive","install":"vanilla","live":true},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31pro","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31pro","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31pro","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"}
]Coverage rationale: PR #1644 changes Atlas catalog claim metadata for model/provider versions, so this focused matrix exercises graph/catalog-consuming adapter paths, Gemini 3.1 Pro Preview mapping, an Anthropic direct baseline, a bridged vanilla lane, and BP predefined/hooks/create lanes. Overall verdict: not passed yet; final QA result is pending completion of the live-stack workflow. |
Live-stack QAResult: non-terminal after 20-minute polling window. Actions run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31061293660
Overall verdict: not passed yet. The workflow was still running when the predefined QA process hit its 20-minute polling timeout; Matrix dispatched: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31pro","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true},
{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31pro","mode":"bridged-interactive","install":"vanilla","live":true},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31pro","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"anthropic-sonnet46","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"}
]Notes: the matrix targets the Gemini 3.1 Pro Preview catalog alias, a Foundry provider baseline, and BP predefined/create graph-consuming paths. Mistral Large 3 and Cohere Transcribe are not available live-stack model axes in the current workflow, so they were not directly dispatchable here. |
|
This needs changes before merge. The PR adds accepted catalog claims, but it does not add the evidence nodes or the canonical topology needed to make those claims auditable and queryable. Blockers:
Major issues:
QA:
Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Live-stack QAResult: not complete within the QA wait window. Actions run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31061273044 The focused adversarial matrix was dispatched for
Tested matrix: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31pro","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31pro","mode":"bridged-interactive","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-deepseek","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31pro","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"}
]Overall verdict: pending / not passed yet because the workflow had not reached a terminal conclusion during the QA polling window. |
Live-stack QAResult: not passed yet - the adversarial live-stack QA run was still Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31138600921 Current job status
Matrix tested
Coverage rationale: PR #1644 changes Atlas catalog claim metadata for model/provider version facts. This focused adversarial matrix covers Gemini catalog/model mapping, Foundry/OpenAI and Anthropic provider baselines, and BP predefined/create paths without dispatching the full cross-product. Overall verdict: not passed yet. No live-stack scenario failure was observed before timeout, but the workflow had not reached a terminal conclusion, so this is pending QA evidence rather than a pass. |
Live-stack QAResult: not passed / timed out queued. The adversarial live-stack QA workflow was dispatched, but the run was still queued after the predefined 20-minute polling window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31138604495 Current job state
Matrix tested
Coverage rationale: PR #1644 changes Atlas catalog claim metadata, so this focused adversarial matrix targets Gemini 3.1 Pro Preview catalog/provider naming, Foundry and Anthropic provider baselines, and BP predefined/create paths. Overall verdict: not passed. No live-stack scenario failure was observed, but the workflow did not reach executable scenario jobs or a terminal success result within the QA window. |
Live-stack QAResult: not passed / timed out. The adversarial live-stack QA workflow was dispatched for Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31138608618 Current job state
Matrix tested
Overall verdict: not passed yet. No live-stack scenario failure was observed; the run remained queued before |
Live-stack QAResult: not passed / timed out pending runner start. The focused adversarial live-stack QA run was dispatched, but the workflow was still queued when the predefined 20-minute polling window elapsed. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31138608618
Matrix tested
Coverage rationale: PR #1644 changes Atlas catalog metadata for model/provider version claims. The matrix targets Overall verdict: not passed yet. The run dispatched and matrix computation passed, but live-stack execution did not start before timeout. |
Live-stack QAResult: not passed / pending. The focused adversarial live-stack QA run was dispatched for Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31138609233 Current job status
Matrix tested
Overall verdict: not passed yet. |
Live-stack QAResult: not passed / pending. The adversarial live-stack QA workflow was dispatched, but it did not reach a pass/fail conclusion during the 20-minute polling window. The run was still queued when the wait step timed out. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31138625077 Current job status
Matrix tested
Overall verdict: not passed yet. |
|
Adversarial review result: request changes. This PR should not merge as-is. It adds accepted Atlas catalog claims, but the claims point at missing evidence and, in several places, missing or stale canonical topology. Blockers
Major Issues
QA
Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
|
Adversarial review result: request changes. This PR should not merge as-is. It adds accepted Atlas catalog claims, but the claims are not backed by resolvable evidence and several subject/provider topology updates requested by the linked issues are missing. QA also did not produce a passing live-stack result. Blockers
Major issues
QAI dispatched Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Live-stack QAResult: not passed / pending. The adversarial live-stack QA workflow was dispatched, but it did not reach a terminal result within the 20-minute polling window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31138713619 Current job status
No live-stack scenario jobs had started before the wait window expired. Matrix tested
Coverage rationale: PR #1644 changes Atlas catalog claim metadata. This focused adversarial matrix exercises Gemini catalog/model mapping through codex and gemini adapters, Foundry and Anthropic baselines through claude, BP predefined bridged-hooks execution, and BP create interactive process coverage. Mistral Large 3 and Cohere Transcribe are not direct live-stack model axes in the current workflow. Overall verdict: not passed yet because the workflow remained non-terminal during the process wait window. |
|
GitHub rejected a formal request-changes review for this actor, so posting the review decision as a PR comment. Adversarial review result: request changes. I am rejecting this PR because it has blocking provenance/topology issues and QA is not passed. Blockers
Major issues
QAQA is not approval evidence. Dispatch workflow Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Live-stack QAResult: not passed / timed out pending. The adversarial live-stack QA workflow was dispatched for Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31138717634 Current job status
Matrix tested
Overall verdict: not passed yet. No live-stack scenario failure was observed, but the workflow had not started |
|
Adversarial CI review result: request changes. This PR adds accepted Atlas catalog claims, but the graph evidence and canonical topology needed to make those claims auditable/queryable are missing. QA was also inconclusive: qa-dispatch run https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31138486079 was still in progress after 25 one-minute polls. Blockers
Major issues
QA
Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Live-stack QAResult: not passed / timed out queued. The adversarial live-stack QA workflow was dispatched for Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31230751992 Job status at timeout
Matrix tested
Overall verdict: not passed yet. Build setup and matrix computation passed, but all live-stack scenario jobs were still queued when the QA polling window expired, so this run is not approval evidence. |
Live-stack QAResult: not passed / timed out pending. The adversarial live-stack workflow was dispatched for Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31230788260 Current job status
Matrix tested
Coverage rationale: PR #1644 changes Atlas catalog claim metadata. This focused adversarial matrix exercises Gemini catalog/model mapping through codex and gemini adapters, Foundry and Anthropic baselines through claude, BP predefined bridged-hooks execution, and BP create interactive process coverage. Mistral Large 3 and Cohere Transcribe are not direct live-stack model axes in the current workflow. Overall verdict: not passed yet because the workflow remained non-terminal during the process wait window. |
Live-stack QAResult: not passed / timed out pending. The adversarial live-stack QA workflow was dispatched for Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31230750587 Current job status
No live-stack scenario jobs had started before the wait window expired. Matrix tested
Coverage rationale: PR #1644 changes Atlas graph catalog metadata claims. This focused adversarial matrix exercises Gemini-facing catalog/model paths through Codex and Gemini, Foundry and Anthropic baselines through Claude, BP predefined bridged-hooks execution, and BP create interactive process coverage. Overall verdict: not passed yet because the workflow remained non-terminal during the process wait window. |
Live-stack QAResult: not passed / timed out pending. The adversarial live-stack QA workflow was dispatched for Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31230826036 Current job status
No live-stack scenario jobs reached terminal success before timeout. Matrix tested
Coverage rationale: PR #1644 changes Atlas catalog claim metadata for model/provider version evidence. This focused adversarial matrix exercises Gemini 3.1 Pro Preview through Codex and Gemini adapter paths, Foundry/OpenAI-compatible and Anthropic direct baselines, and BP predefined/create plugin paths. Mistral Large 3, Cohere Transcribe, Together, and Groq are not direct live-stack model axes in the current workflow. Overall verdict: not passed yet because the workflow remained non-terminal during the process wait window. |
Live-stack QAResult: not passed / timed out queued. The adversarial live-stack QA workflow was dispatched for Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31230809781 Current job status
Matrix tested
Coverage rationale: PR #1644 changes Atlas catalog-meta claim metadata for model/provider version evidence. This focused adversarial matrix exercises Gemini 3.1 Pro Preview paths through codex and gemini adapters, Foundry and Anthropic baselines through Claude, plus BP predefined bridged-hooks and BP create interactive process coverage. Mistral Large 3 and Cohere Transcribe are not direct live-stack model axes in the current workflow. Overall verdict: not passed yet. No live-stack scenario failure was observed, but the workflow was still queued after the polling window, so this run cannot be used as passing QA evidence. |
Live-stack QAResult: not passed / timed out. The adversarial live-stack QA workflow was dispatched for Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31230786064 Current job status
Matrix tested
Coverage rationale: PR #1644 changes Atlas catalog metadata claims for model/provider version coverage. This focused adversarial matrix exercises Gemini model mapping through codex and gemini adapters, Foundry and direct Anthropic baselines through claude, and BP predefined/create paths including bridged-hooks. Mistral Large 3 and Cohere Transcribe are not direct live-stack workflow model axes in the current workflow. Overall verdict: not passed yet because the workflow remained non-terminal during the QA wait window. |
Live-stack QAResult: not passed / timed out while in progress. The adversarial live-stack QA workflow was dispatched for Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31230802466 Current job status
Matrix tested
Coverage rationale: PR #1644 changes Atlas catalog claim metadata for Gemini, Mistral, Cohere, Together, and Groq model/provider version evidence. This focused adversarial matrix exercises Gemini catalog/model mapping paths, Foundry and Anthropic baselines, vanilla adapter compatibility, BP predefined bridged-hooks execution, and BP create-mode execution without running the full cross-product. Overall verdict: not passed yet. No live-stack scenario failure was observed, but the workflow was still non-terminal at timeout, so this run cannot be used as passing QA evidence. |
Live-stack QAResult: not passed / timed out pending. The adversarial live-stack QA workflow was dispatched for Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31230814844 Current job status
Matrix tested
Coverage rationale: PR #1644 changes Atlas model/provider catalog claim metadata. This focused adversarial matrix exercises Gemini catalog/model mapping through codex and gemini adapters, Foundry and Anthropic baselines through claude, BP predefined bridged-hooks execution, and BP create interactive process coverage. Mistral Large 3, Cohere Transcribe, Together, and Groq are not direct live-stack model axes in the current workflow. Overall verdict: not passed yet because the workflow remained non-terminal during the process wait window. |
|
GitHub rejected a formal request-changes review for this actor ( Adversarial CI review result: request changes. This PR adds accepted Atlas catalog claims, but the graph evidence and canonical topology needed to make those claims auditable and queryable are missing. QA also did not reach a terminal pass. Blockers
Major issues
QA
Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
|
Adversarial CI review result: request changes. This PR still has blocking Atlas graph provenance/topology issues, and QA is not passing approval evidence. The decision is reject/request changes. Blockers
Major Issues
QAQA is not approval evidence. I dispatched Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
|
Adversarial CI review result: request changes. This PR should not merge as-is. It adds accepted Atlas catalog claims, but the claims point at missing evidence and do not add the canonical model/provider topology requested by the linked issues. QA is also not passing. Blockers
Major issues
Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
|
Adversarial CI review result: request changes. This PR should not merge as-is. It adds accepted Atlas catalog claims, but the claims point at missing evidence and do not add the canonical model/provider topology requested by the linked issues. QA and required checks are also not passing approval evidence. Blockers
Major issues
Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Live-stack QAResult: not passed / timed out pending. The adversarial live-stack QA workflow was dispatched for Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31286726637 Current job status
Matrix tested
Coverage rationale: PR #1644 changes Atlas graph catalog metadata claims. This focused adversarial matrix exercises Gemini catalog/model mapping through codex and gemini adapters, Foundry and Anthropic baselines through claude, BP predefined bridged-hooks execution, and BP create interactive process coverage. Mistral Large 3, Cohere Transcribe, Together, and Groq are not direct live-stack model axes in the current workflow. Overall verdict: not passed yet because the workflow remained non-terminal during the process wait window. |
Live-stack QAResult: not passed / timed out pending. The adversarial live-stack QA workflow was dispatched for Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31286734368 Current job status
Matrix tested
Coverage rationale: PR #1644 changes Atlas catalog metadata claims for model/provider version evidence. This focused adversarial matrix covers Gemini 3.1 Pro Preview catalog/model mapping through Codex and Gemini adapters, Foundry and Anthropic baselines through Claude, BP predefined bridged-hooks execution, and BP create interactive process coverage. Mistral Large 3, Cohere Transcribe, Together, and Groq are not direct live-stack model axes in the current workflow. Overall verdict: not passed yet because the workflow remained queued/non-terminal during the process wait window. |
|
Adversarial CI review result: request changes. This PR should not merge as-is. It adds accepted Atlas catalog claims, but the claims point at missing evidence and do not add the canonical model/provider topology requested by the linked issues. QA is also not passing approval evidence. Blockers
Major Issues
Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Live-stack QAResult: not passed / timed out pending. The adversarial live-stack QA workflow was dispatched for Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31286760377 Job status
Matrix tested
Coverage rationale: PR #1644 changes Atlas graph catalog claim metadata, so this focused matrix targets Gemini/catalog-consuming harness paths, Foundry and Anthropic baselines, and BP predefined/create paths. Mistral Large 3, Cohere Transcribe, Together, and Groq are not direct live-stack model axes in the current workflow. Overall verdict: not passed yet. No live-stack scenario failure was observed, but the run was non-terminal during the QA window and cannot be used as passing evidence. |
Live-stack QAResult: not passed / timed out pending. The adversarial live-stack workflow was dispatched for Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31286760355 Current observed status
Matrix tested
Coverage rationale: PR #1644 changes Atlas graph catalog claim metadata. This matrix exercises Gemini catalog/model mapping through codex and gemini adapters, Foundry and Anthropic baselines through claude, BP predefined bridged-hooks execution, and BP create interactive process coverage. Mistral Large 3, Cohere Transcribe, Together, and Groq are not direct live-stack model axes in the current workflow. Overall verdict: not passed yet. The workflow was dispatched successfully, but it produced no terminal passing QA evidence inside the process wait window. |
Live-stack QAResult: not passed / timed out pending. The adversarial live-stack QA workflow was dispatched for Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31286761964 Current job status
Note: successful polls through Matrix tested
Coverage rationale: PR #1644 changes Atlas catalog metadata claims for model/provider version evidence. This focused adversarial matrix exercises Gemini catalog/model mapping through codex and gemini adapters, Foundry and Anthropic baselines through claude, BP predefined bridged-hooks execution, and BP create interactive process coverage. Mistral Large 3, Cohere Transcribe, Together, and Groq are not direct live-stack model axes in the current workflow. Overall verdict: not passed yet because the workflow remained non-terminal during the process wait window. |
Live-stack QAResult: not passed / queued timeout. The adversarial live-stack QA workflow was dispatched for Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31286753289 Current job status
Matrix tested
Coverage rationale: PR #1644 changes Atlas catalog metadata claims for model/provider versions. This focused adversarial matrix exercises Gemini 3.1 Pro Preview through codex and gemini adapters, Foundry and Anthropic baselines through claude, BP predefined bridged-hooks execution, and BP create interactive process coverage. Mistral, Cohere Transcribe, Together, and Groq are not direct live-stack model axes in the current workflow. Overall verdict: not passed yet. No live-stack scenario failure was observed, but the workflow did not reach terminal passing QA evidence within the wait window. |
|
Adversarial CI review result: request changes. This PR should not merge as-is. It adds accepted Atlas catalog claims, but the claims point at missing evidence and do not add the canonical model/provider topology requested by the linked issues. QA is also not passing. Blockers
Major issues
Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
|
GitHub rejected a formal request-changes review for this actor ( Adversarial CI review result: request changes. This PR should not merge as-is. It adds accepted Atlas catalog claims, but the claims point at missing evidence and do not add the canonical model/provider topology required by the linked issues. QA also did not reach a terminal pass. Blockers
Major issues
QAI dispatched Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Summary
Issues
Refs #1639
Refs #1640
Refs #1641
Refs #1642
Refs #1643
Verification
Note: atlas build exits 0, but the existing library bridge quality report still prints its pre-existing semantic/edge validation failures and YAML BAD_ALIAS warnings.