Feature/verse practice and scaffold take 1 #51
Conversation
neiljaywarner
commented
Jul 19, 2025
neiljaywarner
commented
- Scaffold for mockup for verse quiz screen from stitch (ie bottom navigation)
- Centralized theming
- Talker and retrofit (See Feature/verse practice and scaffold take 1 fix network calls #50 and network fixes and basic auth)
- Mockup only for verse screen
This commit introduces GoRouter for tab-based navigation, along with a parallel test runner and related test updates.
Key changes:
- **GoRouter Integration:** Refactored `main.dart` to use GoRouter with `ShellRoute` for tabbed navigation (Home, Verse, Ref, Settings). The "Verse" tab is now the default.
- **Test Runner:** Added `run_parallel_memverse_tests.py` to execute various tests (ADB screenshot, Maestro, integration, widget BDD, feature BDD) concurrently. This script also manages emulator creation and startup.
- **Provider Mocking:** Implemented `INTEGRATION_TEST` dart-define flag to switch to mock providers (e.g., `NoOpAnalyticsService`, `FakeVerseRepository`) and enable dummy user mode for testing.
- **Verse Repository Simplification:** Streamlined `VerseRepository` and related files. The live repository implementation was removed, and `FakeVerseRepository` is now used by default.
- **UI Updates:**
- `VerseTextQuizScreen`: Replaced search/notification/profile icons with logout and feedback icons.
- `VerseCard`: Made color constants `const`.
- **Accessibility Test:** Added `bottom_nav_accessibility_test.dart` to verify contrast ratios for bottom navigation bar colors.
- **Domain Logic:**
- `Verse`: Changed field order and default translation to "NIV".
- `VerseReferenceValidator`: Simplified validation logic.
- **Documentation:** Updated `temporarily_ditl.md` with a task plan and checklist for GoRouter integration and testing.
The test suite now includes an ADB screenshot taken after app launch, stored in `test_results/emulator_screen.png`.
This commit introduces a centralized theming system using `AppThemes` for light and dark modes, ensuring consistent UI across the application. It also includes several code quality improvements:
- **Theming:**
- Created `AppThemes` class with light and dark `ThemeData`.
- Defined color constants in `colors.dart` and theme-specific colors in `themes.dart`.
- Applied the new themes in `app.dart`, ensuring `BetterFeedback` uses the correct theme based on platform brightness.
- Updated `SignedInNavScaffold` to use theme colors and styles for the bottom navigation bar.
- **Code Quality & Refactoring:**
- Replaced stateful `SignedInNavScaffold` with a `HookWidget` for simpler state management.
- Utilized `const` constructors where possible for improved performance (e.g., `Verse` instances, `TextStyle`).
- Added localization strings for navigation bar items (`Home`, `Verse`, `Ref`, `Settings`).
- Improved `bootstrap.dart` to handle `CLIENT_ID` more robustly, including a 'debug' fallback for development.
- Updated `analyticsServiceProvider` and `authServiceProvider` to use mock/logging services when `CLIENT_ID` is 'debug' or empty, facilitating local development and testing.
- Updated `verseRepositoryProvider` to use `FakeVerseRepository` when `CLIENT_ID` is 'debug' or empty.
- Corrected `main.dart` to consistently use the `App` widget as the entry point, ensuring theme propagation.
- **Miscellaneous:**
- Added a `temporary_ditl.md` file for tracking theming debug steps.
- Ensured `AuthService.clientSecret` correctly reads from environment variables.
- Minor cleanups and formatting.
This commit adds the following markdown files: - `DESIGN_SYSTEM_BEST_PRACTICES.md`: Outlines best practices for using the centralized design system. - `proposed_pr_description.md`: A template for future PRs related to design system changes. - `fix_prod_network_calls.md`: A guide for debugging and implementing production network calls. - `split_tokens_themes_info.md`: Describes an advanced approach to splitting tokens and themes for scalability. Additionally, this commit updates `lib/src/constants/themes.dart` to: - Include a detailed usage guide at the top of the file. - Centralize all design tokens (colors, spacing, typography, radii, etc.). - Refactor existing theme definitions to use the new tokens. - Add new tokens for feedback theme and secondary buttons.
Refactor: Standardize AppBar, improve dark mode, and enhance Home/Settings tabs
This commit introduces a reusable `MemverseAppBar` for consistent branding across screens and refines the dark mode theme for better visual appeal.
Key changes:
- **`MemverseAppBar`:**
- Created a new widget for a standardized app bar with "Memverse" and a suffix (e.g., "Ref", "Home").
- Integrated feedback and logout actions directly into the `MemverseAppBar`.
- Applied the new app bar to `MemversePage`, `VerseTextQuizScreen`, `HomeTab`, and `SettingsTab`.
- **Dark Mode Enhancements:**
- Adjusted dark mode background colors for scaffold, navigation bar, and cards for improved contrast and aesthetics.
- **Home Tab (`HomeTab.dart`):**
- Moved home screen content from `SignedInNavScaffold` to a dedicated `HomeTab.dart` file.
- Added introductory text about Memverse and a clickable link to memverse.com.
- Included demo account credentials (email/password) with copy-to-clipboard functionality.
- Improved layout to prevent `RenderFlex` overflow issues.
- **Settings Tab (`SettingsTab.dart`):**
- Created a new `SettingsTab.dart` file with a placeholder UI for future settings options (default translation, reminder notifications).
- **Refactoring & Cleanup:**
- Removed redundant feedback and logout logic from `MemversePage` (now handled by `MemverseAppBar`).
- Removed unused `_HomeTab` and `_SettingsTab` from `SignedInNavScaffold`.
- Added `url_launcher` dependency for opening web links.
- **Testing:**
- Added basic widget tests for `HomeTab` (feedback button) and `MemverseAppBar` (feedback button and snackbar).
- Temporarily disabled an unimplemented step definition in BDD tests.
…/subtitle "works"
…ain_development next
* Refactor: Use Dio for auth, remove http fallback - Modified `AuthService` to exclusively use the `dio` package for authentication requests, removing the fallback to the `http` package. This simplifies the authentication logic and dependency management. - Updated `LoginPage` to use `OutlinedButton` instead of `ElevatedButton` for the login button and changed icon colors. - Enhanced `main_production.dart` and `main_staging.dart` to require and log the `CLIENT_ID` passed via `--dart-define` for better configuration management and debugging. - Removed redundant debug logging for successful authentication in `auth_providers.dart`. * refactor to use retrofit for auth and run codegen and fix a test * work in progress for authapi * Added talker. Now we should have enough to troubleshoot * NOTE: Signin works now Refactor: Improve auth service and add client secret check - Updated `AuthService` to use Basic authentication with `clientId` and `clientSecret`. - Added a check in `bootstrap.dart` to ensure `MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY` (clientSecret) is provided as a dart-define variable. If not, a `ConfigurationErrorWidget` is displayed. - Refactored `authServiceProvider` to set appropriate Dio headers for JSON content type and User-Agent. - The `ConfigurationErrorWidget` now instructs users to run the app with `flutter run --dart-define=CLIENT_ID=your_client_id` and also implies the need for `MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY`. - Removed an unused `_tokenPath` constant from `AuthService`. - Added a TODO to cleanup unnecessary code in `bootstrap.dart`. * ** NOTE: THIS IS The old live verse repository that got removed on accident. TODO: use retrofit, probably in otherr jira ticket. feat: Implement live API integration for fetching Bible verses This commit introduces the `LiveVerseRepository` which fetches Bible verses from the memverse.com API. Key changes: - Created `LiveVerseRepository` to interact with the live API. - Implemented `getVerses` method to fetch and parse verse data. - Added Dio for HTTP requests with timeout and content-type configurations. - Integrated TalkerDioLogger for logging network requests and responses in debug/non-production environments. - Utilizes an authentication token from `AuthService` for API requests. - Parses JSON response into a list of `Verse` objects. - Updated `verseRepositoryProvider` to use `LiveVerseRepository` instead of `FakeVerseRepository`. --------- Co-authored-by: neil warner <[email protected]>
✅ Deploy Preview for memverse-demo ready!
To edit notification comments on pull requests, go to your Netlify project configuration. |
📝 WalkthroughSummary by CodeRabbit
WalkthroughCentralizes theming and design tokens, adds GoRouter-based tab navigation and signed-in scaffold, introduces Retrofit-based AuthApi and dummy/mock auth flows, reorganizes verse/ref quiz features, updates API base to /api/v1, adds localization keys, documentation, tests, and platform deployment bumps. Changes
Sequence Diagram(s)sequenceDiagram
participant Entry as main_* (flavor)
participant Bootstrap as bootstrap()
participant Container as ProviderContainer
participant App as App Widget
participant Providers as Riverpod providers
participant AuthSvc as AuthService
participant UI as SignedInNavScaffold / AuthWrapper
Entry->>Bootstrap: bootstrap(App.new)
Bootstrap->>Bootstrap: validate CLIENT_ID & clientSecret
alt debug & CLIENT_ID missing
Bootstrap->>Bootstrap: allow 'debug' fallback
end
Bootstrap->>Container: create ProviderContainer with Talker observer
Bootstrap->>App: run App wrapped in BetterFeedback
App->>Container: UncontrolledProviderScope (external container)
Container->>Providers: initialize providers (auth, analytics, etc.)
Providers->>AuthSvc: create/select AuthService (Mock or Live)
alt AUTOSIGNIN / dummy user
AuthSvc->>UI: show SignedInNavScaffold
else normal flow
AuthSvc->>UI: AuthWrapper -> Login or SignedInNavScaffold based on auth state
end
Estimated code review effort🎯 4 (Complex) | ⏱️ ~75 minutes Areas to focus during review:
Possibly related PRs
Suggested reviewers
Poem
Pre-merge checks and finishing touches✅ Passed checks (3 passed)
✨ Finishing touches
🧪 Generate unit tests (beta)
Thanks for using CodeRabbit! It's free for OSS, and your support helps us grow. If you like it, consider giving us a shout-out. Comment |
coderabbitai
bot
requested review from
TheophilusOjukwuII,
elivesay and
njwandroid
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 31
🔭 Outside diff range comments (4)
test/question_section_test.dart (1)
6-8: Fix import paths to resolve pipeline failures.The imports are still pointing to the old
verse/presentation/widgetsdirectory, but these widgets have been moved to theref_quizmodule as part of the feature reorganization. This is causing the pipeline failures.Update the import paths:
-import 'package:memverse/src/features/verse/presentation/widgets/question_section.dart'; -import 'package:memverse/src/features/verse/presentation/widgets/verse_card.dart'; -import 'package:memverse/src/features/verse/presentation/widgets/verse_reference_form.dart'; +import 'package:memverse/src/features/ref_quiz/widgets/question_section.dart'; +import 'package:memverse/src/features/ref_quiz/widgets/verse_card.dart'; +import 'package:memverse/src/features/ref_quiz/widgets/verse_reference_form.dart';test/verse_test.dart (1)
17-27: Align tests with the new default translation and fix the custom‐translation caseThe
Verseconstructor inlib/src/features/verse/domain/verse.dartnow uses a default of'NIV', but your tests still expect'NLT'and never actually pass a custom translation. Update the tests as follows:• In
test/verse_test.dart, first test should expect'NIV'instead of'NLT'.
• In the “custom translation” test, pass thetranslationparameter to the constructor.Example diff:
--- test/verse_test.dart @@ group('Verse', () { test('should create a verse with required parameters', () { @@ - expect(verse.translation, equals('NLT')); // default value + expect(verse.translation, equals('NIV')); // default changed to NIV }); test('should create a verse with custom translation', () { @@ - const verse = Verse(text: text, reference: reference); + const verse = Verse( + text: text, + reference: reference, + translation: translation, // now passing custom translation + );lib/src/features/auth/presentation/login_page.dart (1)
212-215: Fix the type inference issue for MaterialPageRoute.The pipeline indicates a type inference failure. Add explicit type argument to resolve this.
Apply this diff to fix the type inference issue:
- onPressed: () { - Navigator.of( - context, - ).push(MaterialPageRoute(builder: (context) => const SignupPage())); - }, + onPressed: () { + Navigator.of( + context, + ).push(MaterialPageRoute<void>(builder: (context) => const SignupPage())); + },lib/src/common/services/analytics_service.dart (1)
278-317: Remove unused detector methods.The pipeline correctly identifies that
_isAndroidEmulator()and_isIOSSimulator()methods are unused and should be removed to clean up the codebase.- Future<bool> _isAndroidEmulator() async { - try { - // Try multiple methods to detect Android emulator - final result = await Process.run('getprop', [ - 'ro.kernel.qemu', - ]).timeout(const Duration(seconds: 2), onTimeout: () => ProcessResult(0, 1, '', 'timeout')); - - if (result.exitCode == 0 && result.stdout.toString().trim() == '1') { - return true; - } - - final buildFingerprint = await Process.run('getprop', [ - 'ro.build.fingerprint', - ]).timeout(const Duration(seconds: 2), onTimeout: () => ProcessResult(0, 1, '', 'timeout')); - - if (buildFingerprint.exitCode == 0) { - final fingerprint = buildFingerprint.stdout.toString().toLowerCase(); - return fingerprint.contains('generic') || - fingerprint.contains('emulator') || - fingerprint.contains('sdk'); - } - - return false; - } catch (e) { - AppLogger.w('Could not detect Android emulator: $e'); - return false; - } - } - - Future<bool> _isIOSSimulator() async { - try { - final envResult = await Process.run('printenv', [ - 'SIMULATOR_DEVICE_NAME', - ]).timeout(const Duration(seconds: 2), onTimeout: () => ProcessResult(0, 1, '', 'timeout')); - return envResult.exitCode == 0 && envResult.stdout.toString().isNotEmpty; - } catch (e) { - AppLogger.w('Could not detect iOS simulator: $e'); - return false; - } - }
🧹 Nitpick comments (34)
setup.md (1)
95-96: Address cspell warnings and improve command readability.The flutter run command update is correct but has two issues:
Cspell warnings: Words like "signup", "POSTHOG", and "posthog" are flagged as unknown. Consider adding these to the cspell dictionary or project configuration.
Command readability: The long command could be better formatted for readability.
Consider formatting the command like this for better readability:
-flutter run --dart-define=CLIENT_ID=$MEMVERSE_CLIENT_ID --dart-define=POSTHOG_MEMVERSE_API_KEY=$POSTHOG_MEMVERSE_API_KEY --flavor production --target lib/main_production.dart --dart-define=MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY=$MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY +flutter run \ + --dart-define=CLIENT_ID=$MEMVERSE_CLIENT_ID \ + --dart-define=POSTHOG_MEMVERSE_API_KEY=$POSTHOG_MEMVERSE_API_KEY \ + --flavor production \ + --target lib/main_production.dart \ + --dart-define=MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY=$MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEYlib/src/constants/colors.dart (1)
3-6: Maintain consistency in color definitions.The color constant definitions look good for centralizing theme colors. However, there's an inconsistency in how colors are defined.
Consider using a consistent approach for all color definitions:
-const Color mvHomeTitleGreen = Colors.green; // for home tab title text +const Color mvHomeTitleGreen = Color(0xFF4CAF50); // for home tab title textThis ensures all colors are explicitly defined with hex values, making them easier to customize and maintain consistency across the design system.
lib/src/features/ref_quiz/README.md (1)
6-7: Fix grammatical issue in documentation.The static analysis tool identified a missing subject in the sentence. Consider revising for better readability.
-- Originally located in the verse presentation code. -- Should be launched from the 'Ref' tab in main signed-in navigation. +- Originally located in the verse presentation code. +- It should be launched from the 'Ref' tab in main signed-in navigation.test/widget/home_tab_test.dart (1)
7-26: Consider using localized strings and key-based assertions for better test robustness.The test uses hard-coded English text
"What's wrong?"which could break if the feedback package is localized or if the text changes. Consider using widget keys or more specific widget types for assertions.// Instead of hard-coded text, consider: - expect(find.text("What's wrong?"), findsNothing); + expect(find.byType(FeedbackWidget), findsNothing); // And after tap: - expect(find.text("What's wrong?"), findsOneWidget); + expect(find.byType(FeedbackWidget), findsOneWidget);Additionally, the comment on line 12 suggests incomplete feedback configuration. Consider either implementing the palette configuration or removing the TODO comment.
lib/main_staging.dart (1)
6-13: Consider improving error handling for better user experience.While the validation logic is correct, throwing an exception directly in
main()could cause abrupt app termination. Consider wrapping the bootstrap call in a try-catch block or using a more graceful error handling approach.void main() async { const clientId = String.fromEnvironment('CLIENT_ID'); if (clientId.isEmpty || clientId == 'debug') { - throw Exception( - 'CLIENT_ID must be provided and must not be "debug" for STAGING.\n' - 'Did you launch with: flutter run --dart-define=CLIENT_ID=... --flavor staging --target lib/main_staging.dart?', - ); + if (kDebugMode) { + print('ERROR: CLIENT_ID must be provided and must not be "debug" for STAGING.'); + print('Did you launch with: flutter run --dart-define=CLIENT_ID=... --flavor staging --target lib/main_staging.dart?'); + } + return; }lib/src/features/settings/settings_tab.dart (1)
4-36: Well-structured placeholder implementation with room for improvement.The settings tab follows good Flutter practices with proper widget structure and spacing. However, consider these improvements for better consistency:
- Localize hard-coded strings:
- Text('Settings', style: Theme.of(context).textTheme.headlineMedium), + Text(AppLocalizations.of(context).settings, style: Theme.of(context).textTheme.headlineMedium),
- Use theme-based colors for TODO text:
- style: TextStyle(color: Colors.grey), + style: TextStyle(color: Theme.of(context).colorScheme.onSurfaceVariant),
- Consider extracting TODO items into a more structured format:
+ _buildSettingItem( + title: 'Default Translation:', + placeholder: 'TODO: Let user pick translation here', + context: context, + ),The overall structure is solid and provides a good foundation for future settings implementation.
lib/src/features/signed_in/presentation/signed_in_nav_scaffold.dart (2)
16-16: Consider the UX impact of starting with tab index 1.Starting with the Verse Text Quiz tab (index 1) instead of the Home tab (index 0) might be unexpected for users. Consider if this aligns with your UX goals or if it should default to the Home tab.
9-9: Consider moving the tabs array inside the class.While the current approach works, consider moving the
_tabsarray inside theSignedInNavScaffoldclass to improve encapsulation, especially if these tabs are only used by this widget.class SignedInNavScaffold extends HookWidget { const SignedInNavScaffold({super.key}); + static const _tabs = <Widget>[HomeTab(), VerseTextQuizScreen(), MemversePage(), SettingsTab()]; @override Widget build(BuildContext context) {lib/l10n/arb/app_localizations_es.dart (1)
112-112: Consider using "Versículo" instead of "Verso" for biblical context.In biblical/religious contexts, "Versículo" is more commonly used in Spanish to refer to Bible verses, while "Verso" typically refers to poetry verses. Consider updating for better context accuracy:
- String get verse => 'Verso'; + String get verse => 'Versículo';temporary_ditl.md (1)
1-24: Consider relocating this temporary development documentation.This debug checklist is valuable but appears to be temporary development notes. Consider either:
- Moving it to a proper development documentation folder
- Converting it to permanent documentation with better formatting
- Removing it before the final merge if it's no longer needed
Additionally, clarify the "DITL" acronym (likely "Day In The Life") for better readability.
-# NavBar Theming/Entrypoint Debug DITL +# NavBar Theming/Entrypoint Debug - Day In The Life (DITL)lib/src/features/home/home_tab.dart (1)
48-51: Consider using theme colors for consistency.While the blue link color works well, consider using
Theme.of(context).colorScheme.primaryor a defined link color from the centralized theme for better consistency.- style: TextStyle( - color: Colors.blue, - decoration: TextDecoration.underline, - ), + style: TextStyle( + color: Theme.of(context).colorScheme.primary, + decoration: TextDecoration.underline, + ),README.md (1)
49-49: Consider using a proper heading instead of emphasis.The static analysis tool suggests using a heading format for better document structure.
-**AUTOSIGNIN FOR DEMOING** +## AUTOSIGNIN FOR DEMOINGtemporarily_ditl.md (3)
3-3: Fix trailing punctuation in heading.Remove the trailing period from the status heading for consistent markdown style.
-## STATUS: WIP - Working through Maestro automated UI/screenshot validation for dummy sign-in user with mock data and pretty theming. +## STATUS: WIP - Working through Maestro automated UI/screenshot validation for dummy sign-in user with mock data and pretty theming
55-60: Fix nested list indentation.Adjust the indentation of nested list items to follow markdown standards (2 spaces instead of 4).
- - [ ] after_login.png (Home) - - [ ] ref_quiz.png (Ref/Review tab, with reference quiz UI, not blue, should match green/yellow - theme) - - [ ] verse_quiz.png (Verse quiz tab, Gal 5:22 display, green/yellow theme, with AppBar and - pretty - container) + - [ ] after_login.png (Home) + - [ ] ref_quiz.png (Ref/Review tab, with reference quiz UI, not blue, should match green/yellow + theme) + - [ ] verse_quiz.png (Verse quiz tab, Gal 5:22 display, green/yellow theme, with AppBar and + pretty container)
1-1: Address spell checker warnings.Consider adding project-specific terms to the spell checker dictionary or use alternative wording.
The spell checker flags:
- "DITL" (line 1) - consider defining this acronym
- "screencap" (line 42) - could use "screenshot capture"
- "spiritflightapps" (line 72) - this is a valid package name
Also applies to: 42-42, 72-72
split_tokens_themes_info.md (1)
60-62: Improve sentence variety for better readability.Consider varying the sentence beginnings to avoid repetition.
-- When your app is scaling or will need light/dark/multiple brands. -- When designers want independent control over values (from code). -- When you want extreme workshop/future-proofing for your visual system. +- For apps that are scaling or will need light/dark/multiple brands. +- To give designers independent control over values (from code). +- For extreme workshop/future-proofing of your visual system.lib/src/features/auth/presentation/providers/auth_providers.dart (1)
78-79: Consider centralizing Talker configuration.The comment suggests potential for Discord webhook integration. Consider if the Talker instance should be configured in the bootstrap layer for global consistency.
lib/src/features/verse_text_quiz/widgets/verse_text_quiz_screen.dart (2)
99-99: Implement button callbacks or add TODO comments.Multiple buttons have empty
onPressedcallbacks. This could cause confusion about whether the functionality is missing or intentionally disabled.Would you like me to:
- Add TODO comments explaining what each button should do?
- Generate placeholder implementations with appropriate feedback?
- Open an issue to track the implementation of these features?
Also applies to: 132-132
142-142: Fix typo in hint text.There's a typo in the TextField hint text.
-hintText: 'But the fruit of the Spirit it love...', +hintText: 'But the fruit of the Spirit is love...',test/memverse_page_test.dart (1)
364-364: Consider making the static text check more robust.The test relies on a specific static text that might change during development.
Consider checking for the widget type or a more stable identifier:
-expect(find.textContaining('Gal 5:22'), findsOneWidget); // static screen check +// Verify the screen is displayed +expect(find.byType(VerseTextQuizScreen), findsOneWidget); +// Optionally check for key UI elements +expect(find.byType(TextField), findsOneWidget);DESIGN_SYSTEM_BEST_PRACTICES.md (1)
19-19: Consider providing concrete examples for spacing constants.While the guideline mentions named constants, it would be helpful to show examples.
Consider adding an example:
- If a widget requires custom padding, always use named constants (`kPadding`, `kVerticalPadding`, etc.). Example: `const kPadding = 16.0;`, `const kPaddingSmall = 8.0;`, `const kPaddingLarge = 24.0;`run_parallel_memverse_tests.py (1)
160-160: Add newline at end of fileAdd a newline character at the end of the file to follow Python conventions.
fix_prod_network_calls.md (3)
76-76: Avoid hardcoded test credentials in documentationThe example contains what appears to be a test password (
testpw). Consider using placeholder values like<password>orYOUR_PASSWORDto avoid any confusion or accidental usage.- -d 'grant_type=password&username=test%40email.com&password=testpw&client_id=xxxx&client_secret=yyyy' + -d 'grant_type=password&username=test%40email.com&password=<password>&client_id=<client_id>&client_secret=<client_secret>'
28-28: Add period after "etc" abbreviationIn American English, abbreviations like "etc." require a period.
- - Confirm: method (POST/GET), URL, required fields (headers, query, body params, content-type), - authentication method (OAuth2, Bearer, etc). + - Confirm: method (POST/GET), URL, required fields (headers, query, body params, content-type), + authentication method (OAuth2, Bearer, etc.).
72-77: Use fenced code blocks consistentlyThe curl example uses inconsistent code block style. Use fenced code blocks throughout the document.
The code block starting at line 72 should maintain consistent formatting with the rest of the document.
proposed_pr_description.md (2)
12-12: Fix typos in technical termsCorrect the following typos:
- Line 12: "appbar" should be "AppBar"
- Line 29: "themeing" should be "theming"
- - All theme-related configuration (light/dark/feedback/card/nav/appbar/Button/etc) is now built + - All theme-related configuration (light/dark/feedback/card/nav/AppBar/Button/etc) is now built- - All entry points (`main.dart`, `main_development.dart`, `main_staging.dart`) reliably funnel - through the `App` widget and the new global theme—no direct widget-level themeing. + - All entry points (`main.dart`, `main_development.dart`, `main_staging.dart`) reliably funnel + through the `App` widget and the new global theme—no direct widget-level theming.Also applies to: 29-29
12-34: Fix list indentation for markdown consistencyThe nested list items use 4 spaces but should use 2 spaces according to markdown standards.
Reduce the indentation of all nested list items from 4 spaces to 2 spaces for consistent markdown formatting.
lib/src/bootstrap.dart (2)
72-72: Remove or implement the TODO commentThe TODO comment "cleanup what is not needed" should either be addressed or removed if no longer relevant.
Would you like me to help identify what can be cleaned up in the bootstrapProvider?
89-91: Clean up or move the flutter run exampleThe long flutter run command example in the comment should be moved to documentation or formatted better for readability.
Consider moving this detailed command to the README or setup documentation rather than keeping it as a comment in the code.
lib/main.dart (1)
108-120: Implement actual content for placeholder tabsThe HomeTab and SettingsTab widgets are minimal placeholders. Consider adding TODO comments or creating issues to track their implementation.
- Widget build(BuildContext context) => const Center(child: Text('Home')); + Widget build(BuildContext context) => const Center( + child: Text('Home'), + // TODO: Implement home screen content + );lib/src/features/auth/data/auth_service.dart (1)
116-122: Maintain consistency in mock user IDsThe
MockAuthServiceusesuserId: 0while the dummy user also usesuserId: 0. Consider using consistent negative IDs for all test/mock users to avoid conflicts.- userId: 0, + userId: -2, // Use negative IDs for mock/test usersAlso applies to: 128-134
lib/src/constants/themes.dart (1)
125-127: Consider making forceLightMode configurableThe
forceLightModeis hardcoded totrue. For production, this should ideally be configurable through environment variables or user preferences.-const bool forceLightMode = true; +const bool forceLightMode = bool.fromEnvironment('FORCE_LIGHT_MODE', defaultValue: false);lib/src/features/verse/data/verse_repository.dart (2)
41-43: TODO: Implement real repository for productionThe comment indicates that a real repository implementation is needed for production use.
Would you like me to create an issue to track the implementation of the production VerseRepository?
56-57: Consider longer timeout for mobile networksA 5-second timeout might be too short for users on slow mobile networks. Consider increasing it to 15-30 seconds.
- _dio.options.connectTimeout = const Duration(seconds: 5); - _dio.options.receiveTimeout = const Duration(seconds: 5); + _dio.options.connectTimeout = const Duration(seconds: 15); + _dio.options.receiveTimeout = const Duration(seconds: 30);
| import 'package:memverse/src/features/ref_quiz/widgets/ref_quiz/question_history_widget.dart'; | ||
| import 'package:memverse/src/features/ref_quiz/widgets/ref_quiz/verse_card.dart'; |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
💡 Verification agent
🧩 Analysis chain
Critical: Imported widget files do not exist.
The pipeline failures indicate that the imported widget files question_history_widget.dart and verse_card.dart do not exist at the specified paths in lib/src/features/ref_quiz/widgets/ref_quiz/. This will prevent the tests from compiling and running.
Please verify the correct import paths for these widgets:
🏁 Script executed:
#!/bin/bash
# Description: Find the actual location of the widget files
echo "Searching for question_history_widget.dart..."
fd "question_history_widget.dart"
echo "Searching for verse_card.dart..."
fd "verse_card.dart"
echo "Checking ref_quiz directory structure..."
fd . lib/src/features/ref_quiz --type fLength of output: 1050
Fix incorrect import paths in test/verse_widgets_test.dart
The widget files live under lib/src/features/ref_quiz/widgets/ (no extra ref_quiz/ subfolder), so the test imports should be updated accordingly.
• File: test/verse_widgets_test.dart
– Change:
-import 'package:memverse/src/features/ref_quiz/widgets/ref_quiz/question_history_widget.dart';
-import 'package:memverse/src/features/ref_quiz/widgets/ref_quiz/verse_card.dart';
+import 'package:memverse/src/features/ref_quiz/widgets/question_history_widget.dart';
+import 'package:memverse/src/features/ref_quiz/widgets/verse_card.dart';📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| import 'package:memverse/src/features/ref_quiz/widgets/ref_quiz/question_history_widget.dart'; | |
| import 'package:memverse/src/features/ref_quiz/widgets/ref_quiz/verse_card.dart'; | |
| -import 'package:memverse/src/features/ref_quiz/widgets/ref_quiz/question_history_widget.dart'; | |
| -import 'package:memverse/src/features/ref_quiz/widgets/ref_quiz/verse_card.dart'; | |
| +import 'package:memverse/src/features/ref_quiz/widgets/question_history_widget.dart'; | |
| +import 'package:memverse/src/features/ref_quiz/widgets/verse_card.dart'; |
🧰 Tools
🪛 GitHub Actions: memverse
[error] 4-5: Target of URI doesn't exist for multiple imports: 'question_history_widget.dart', 'verse_card.dart' (uri_does_not_exist)
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In test/verse_widgets_test.dart around lines 4 to 5, the import paths
incorrectly include an extra 'ref_quiz/' subfolder. Update the import statements
to remove the redundant 'ref_quiz/' segment so they correctly point to
'lib/src/features/ref_quiz/widgets/question_history_widget.dart' and
'lib/src/features/ref_quiz/widgets/verse_card.dart'.
| Future<void> iShouldSeeAlmostCorrectFeedbackWithOrangeStyling(WidgetTester tester) async { | ||
| throw UnimplementedError(); | ||
| return; | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
💡 Verification agent
🧩 Analysis chain
Consider implementing or removing this test step.
The function now returns immediately without performing any validation, which could lead to false positives in tests. Since the AI summary indicates feedback functionality has been moved to new widgets, either:
- Implement the actual validation logic for orange styling feedback
- Remove this step function and update dependent tests to use the new feedback widgets
Check if this step function is still used in any test files:
🏁 Script executed:
#!/bin/bash
# Description: Find usage of this step function in test files
echo "Searching for usage of iShouldSeeAlmostCorrectFeedbackWithOrangeStyling..."
rg "iShouldSeeAlmostCorrectFeedbackWithOrangeStyling" test/ --type dartLength of output: 944
Implement or remove this no-op test step function
The step function iShouldSeeAlmostCorrectFeedbackWithOrangeStyling currently returns immediately but is invoked in several tests, causing them to pass without actually verifying anything:
• Definition:
- test/step/feedback_validation.dart
- test/features/step/i_should_see_almost_correct_feedback_with_orange_styling.dart
• Usages: - test/happy_path_widget_test.dart (2 calls)
- test/features/happy_path_test.dart (2 calls)
Next steps:
- Implement the actual validation logic to assert orange-styled “almost correct” feedback in the new widgets.
- Or remove this step function entirely and update all dependent tests to directly exercise the new feedback widgets.
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In
test/features/step/i_should_see_almost_correct_feedback_with_orange_styling.dart
at lines 4 to 6, the step function
iShouldSeeAlmostCorrectFeedbackWithOrangeStyling is a no-op but is called in
multiple tests, causing them to pass without real validation. You should either
implement this function to assert that the UI shows the orange-styled "almost
correct" feedback as expected, or remove this function entirely and update all
tests that call it to directly verify the feedback widgets' appearance and
styling.
| Verse({required this.text, required this.reference, this.translation = 'NLT'}); | ||
|
|
||
| final String text; | ||
| const Verse({required this.reference, required this.text, this.translation = 'NIV'}); |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
💡 Verification agent
🧩 Analysis chain
Verify parameter order change doesn't break existing code.
The constructor parameter order has been swapped (reference now precedes text) and the default translation changed from 'NLT' to 'NIV'. The const constructor is a good improvement for immutability.
Run the following script to verify all Verse instantiations match the new parameter order:
🏁 Script executed:
#!/bin/bash
# Description: Check for Verse constructor usage that may be affected by parameter order change
# Search for Verse constructor calls
rg -A 3 "Verse\(" --type dart
# Also check for any remaining 'NLT' references that might need updating
rg "NLT" --type dartLength of output: 5408
Update tests for new default translation
Parameter order swaps are safe (named parameters aren’t positional), but changing the default translation from 'NLT' to 'NIV' breaks two existing tests. Please update them as follows:
• test/verse_test.dart
- expect(verse.translation, equals('NLT')); // default value
+ expect(verse.translation, equals('NIV')); // updated default• test/verse_widgets_test.dart
- const verseTranslation = 'NLT';
+ const verseTranslation = 'NIV';📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| const Verse({required this.reference, required this.text, this.translation = 'NIV'}); | |
| // In test/verse_test.dart | |
| expect(verse.translation, equals('NIV')); // updated default |
| const Verse({required this.reference, required this.text, this.translation = 'NIV'}); | |
| // In test/verse_widgets_test.dart | |
| const verseTranslation = 'NIV'; |
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In lib/src/features/verse/domain/verse.dart at line 2, the default value for the
translation parameter was changed from 'NLT' to 'NIV'. This change breaks
existing tests in test/verse_test.dart and test/verse_widgets_test.dart. To fix
this, update the expected default translation values in those test files from
'NLT' to 'NIV' to align with the new default in the Verse constructor.
| final close = find.byTooltip('Cancel').evaluate().isNotEmpty | ||
| ? find.byTooltip('Cancel') | ||
| : find.byTooltip('Close'); | ||
| if (close.evaluate().isNotEmpty) { | ||
| await tester.tap(close); | ||
| await tester.pumpAndSettle(); | ||
| } else { | ||
| await tester.pumpWidget(const SizedBox()); | ||
| await tester.pumpAndSettle(); | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Improve the fallback logic for dismissing the feedback overlay.
The current fallback logic that pumps an empty SizedBox widget seems unusual and might not properly simulate user interaction. Consider a more robust approach:
- final close = find.byTooltip('Cancel').evaluate().isNotEmpty
- ? find.byTooltip('Cancel')
- : find.byTooltip('Close');
- if (close.evaluate().isNotEmpty) {
- await tester.tap(close);
- await tester.pumpAndSettle();
- } else {
- await tester.pumpWidget(const SizedBox());
- await tester.pumpAndSettle();
- }
+ // Try multiple common close button patterns
+ final closeButtons = [
+ find.byTooltip('Cancel'),
+ find.byTooltip('Close'),
+ find.byIcon(Icons.close),
+ find.byType(BackButton),
+ ];
+
+ bool dismissed = false;
+ for (final closeButton in closeButtons) {
+ if (closeButton.evaluate().isNotEmpty) {
+ await tester.tap(closeButton);
+ await tester.pumpAndSettle();
+ dismissed = true;
+ break;
+ }
+ }
+
+ if (!dismissed) {
+ // If no close button found, try tapping outside the overlay
+ await tester.tapAt(const Offset(10, 10));
+ await tester.pumpAndSettle();
+ }📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| final close = find.byTooltip('Cancel').evaluate().isNotEmpty | |
| ? find.byTooltip('Cancel') | |
| : find.byTooltip('Close'); | |
| if (close.evaluate().isNotEmpty) { | |
| await tester.tap(close); | |
| await tester.pumpAndSettle(); | |
| } else { | |
| await tester.pumpWidget(const SizedBox()); | |
| await tester.pumpAndSettle(); | |
| } | |
| // Try multiple common close button patterns | |
| final closeButtons = [ | |
| find.byTooltip('Cancel'), | |
| find.byTooltip('Close'), | |
| find.byIcon(Icons.close), | |
| find.byType(BackButton), | |
| ]; | |
| bool dismissed = false; | |
| for (final closeButton in closeButtons) { | |
| if (closeButton.evaluate().isNotEmpty) { | |
| await tester.tap(closeButton); | |
| await tester.pumpAndSettle(); | |
| dismissed = true; | |
| break; | |
| } | |
| } | |
| if (!dismissed) { | |
| // If no close button found, try tapping outside the overlay | |
| await tester.tapAt(const Offset(10, 10)); | |
| await tester.pumpAndSettle(); | |
| } |
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In test/widget/memverse_app_bar_test.dart around lines 28 to 37, the fallback
logic uses pumping an empty SizedBox widget, which is not a proper simulation of
user interaction to dismiss the feedback overlay. Replace this fallback by
simulating a more realistic user action, such as tapping outside the overlay or
sending a back button event, to properly dismiss the overlay in tests.
| const autoSignIn = bool.fromEnvironment('AUTOSIGNIN', defaultValue: true); | ||
|
|
||
| if (autoSignIn) { | ||
| AuthService.isDummyUser = true; | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Consider the security implications of defaulting AUTOSIGNIN to true.
While convenient for development, defaulting AUTOSIGNIN to true means that production builds could accidentally enable dummy user mode if the environment variable isn't explicitly set to false. Consider defaulting to false for security:
- const autoSignIn = bool.fromEnvironment('AUTOSIGNIN', defaultValue: true);
+ const autoSignIn = bool.fromEnvironment('AUTOSIGNIN', defaultValue: false);📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| const autoSignIn = bool.fromEnvironment('AUTOSIGNIN', defaultValue: true); | |
| if (autoSignIn) { | |
| AuthService.isDummyUser = true; | |
| } | |
| const autoSignIn = bool.fromEnvironment('AUTOSIGNIN', defaultValue: false); | |
| if (autoSignIn) { | |
| AuthService.isDummyUser = true; | |
| } |
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In lib/main_development.dart around lines 24 to 28, the AUTOSIGNIN environment
variable is defaulted to true, which risks enabling dummy user mode in
production if not explicitly set. Change the defaultValue of AUTOSIGNIN to false
to ensure dummy user mode is only enabled when explicitly intended, improving
security by preventing accidental auto sign-in in production builds.
| AppLogger.d('LOGIN - Received successful response with token $authToken'); | ||
| AppLogger.d('LOGIN - Raw token type: ${authToken.tokenType}'); |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Security: Don't log sensitive authentication tokens
Logging the actual authentication token is a security risk. Tokens should never be logged in plain text.
- AppLogger.d('LOGIN - Received successful response with token $authToken');
+ AppLogger.d('LOGIN - Received successful response');📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| AppLogger.d('LOGIN - Received successful response with token $authToken'); | |
| AppLogger.d('LOGIN - Raw token type: ${authToken.tokenType}'); | |
| AppLogger.d('LOGIN - Received successful response'); | |
| AppLogger.d('LOGIN - Raw token type: ${authToken.tokenType}'); |
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In lib/src/features/auth/data/auth_service.dart around lines 52 to 53, the code
logs the authentication token in plain text, which is a security risk. Remove or
comment out the log statement that outputs the actual token value to prevent
sensitive information from being exposed in logs. You can keep logging
non-sensitive details like the token type if needed.
| static bool isDummyUser = false; | ||
|
|
||
| /// Attempts to login with the provided credentials | ||
| Future<AuthToken> login(String username, String password, String clientId) async { | ||
| // Dummy user fast-path (bypasses all real auth) | ||
| if (username.toLowerCase() == '[email protected]') { | ||
| isDummyUser = true; | ||
| AppLogger.i('Bypassing authentication: using dummysigninuser'); | ||
| final fakeToken = AuthToken( | ||
| accessToken: 'fake_token', | ||
| tokenType: 'bearer', | ||
| scope: 'user', | ||
| createdAt: DateTime.now().millisecondsSinceEpoch ~/ 1000, | ||
| userId: 0, | ||
| ); | ||
| await saveToken(fakeToken); | ||
| return fakeToken; | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Security concern: Dummy user implementation needs safeguards
The dummy user implementation has several concerns:
- Static mutable
isDummyUserflag could cause state issues - Hardcoded email should be a constant
- This bypasses all authentication - ensure it's only enabled in development
userId: 0might conflict with real user IDs
Consider these improvements:
- static bool isDummyUser = false;
+ bool _isDummyUser = false;
+ bool get isDummyUser => _isDummyUser;
+
+ static const String _dummyUserEmail = '[email protected]';
Future<AuthToken> login(String username, String password, String clientId) async {
- if (username.toLowerCase() == '[email protected]') {
- isDummyUser = true;
+ // Only allow dummy user in debug mode
+ if (kDebugMode && username.toLowerCase() == _dummyUserEmail) {
+ _isDummyUser = true;
AppLogger.i('Bypassing authentication: using dummysigninuser');
final fakeToken = AuthToken(
accessToken: 'fake_token',
tokenType: 'bearer',
scope: 'user',
createdAt: DateTime.now().millisecondsSinceEpoch ~/ 1000,
- userId: 0,
+ userId: -1, // Use negative ID to avoid conflicts
);📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| static bool isDummyUser = false; | |
| /// Attempts to login with the provided credentials | |
| Future<AuthToken> login(String username, String password, String clientId) async { | |
| // Dummy user fast-path (bypasses all real auth) | |
| if (username.toLowerCase() == '[email protected]') { | |
| isDummyUser = true; | |
| AppLogger.i('Bypassing authentication: using dummysigninuser'); | |
| final fakeToken = AuthToken( | |
| accessToken: 'fake_token', | |
| tokenType: 'bearer', | |
| scope: 'user', | |
| createdAt: DateTime.now().millisecondsSinceEpoch ~/ 1000, | |
| userId: 0, | |
| ); | |
| await saveToken(fakeToken); | |
| return fakeToken; | |
| } | |
| bool _isDummyUser = false; | |
| bool get isDummyUser => _isDummyUser; | |
| static const String _dummyUserEmail = '[email protected]'; | |
| /// Attempts to login with the provided credentials | |
| Future<AuthToken> login(String username, String password, String clientId) async { | |
| // Only allow dummy user in debug mode | |
| if (kDebugMode && username.toLowerCase() == _dummyUserEmail) { | |
| _isDummyUser = true; | |
| AppLogger.i('Bypassing authentication: using dummysigninuser'); | |
| final fakeToken = AuthToken( | |
| accessToken: 'fake_token', | |
| tokenType: 'bearer', | |
| scope: 'user', | |
| createdAt: DateTime.now().millisecondsSinceEpoch ~/ 1000, | |
| userId: -1, // Use negative ID to avoid conflicts | |
| ); | |
| await saveToken(fakeToken); | |
| return fakeToken; | |
| } |
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In lib/src/features/auth/data/auth_service.dart around lines 25 to 42, the dummy
user login implementation has security risks. Refactor by making the dummy user
email a constant, restrict the dummy login path to only run in development mode
using environment checks, replace the static mutable isDummyUser flag with a
safer mechanism like a local variable or context, and assign a unique userId
that cannot conflict with real users (e.g., a negative number). This will
safeguard against accidental use in production and state issues.
| class FakeVerseRepository implements VerseRepository { | ||
| @override | ||
| Future<List<Verse>> getVerses() async { | ||
| await Future.delayed(const Duration(milliseconds: 100)); |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Fix type inference for Future.delayed
The pipeline reports a type inference failure. Explicitly specify the type argument.
- await Future.delayed(const Duration(milliseconds: 100));
+ await Future<void>.delayed(const Duration(milliseconds: 100));📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| await Future.delayed(const Duration(milliseconds: 100)); | |
| await Future<void>.delayed(const Duration(milliseconds: 100)); |
🧰 Tools
🪛 GitHub Actions: memverse
[warning] 22-22: The type argument(s) of the constructor 'Future.delayed' can't be inferred (inference_failure_on_instance_creation)
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In lib/src/features/verse/data/verse_repository.dart at line 22, the call to
Future.delayed lacks an explicit type argument, causing a type inference
failure. Fix this by specifying the type argument explicitly, for example, use
Future<void>.delayed instead of just Future.delayed to clarify the expected
return type.
| if (authToken == null || authToken.accessToken.isEmpty) { | ||
| AppLogger.e('No auth token available'); | ||
| return []; | ||
| } | ||
|
|
||
| // Use sort parameter to get most recent verses first (Heb 12:1 should appear first) | ||
| final sortOrder = MemverseSortOrder.mostRecentFirst; | ||
|
|
||
| // Construct the URL based on the platform with sort parameter | ||
| final getVersesUrl = kIsWeb | ||
| ? '$webApiPrefix$_memversesPath?sort=${sortOrder.value}' // Use proxy for web | ||
| : '$apiBaseUrl$_memversesPath?sort=${sortOrder.value}'; // Use direct URL otherwise | ||
|
|
||
| // Always output token for debugging (not just in debug mode) | ||
| final redactedToken = token.isEmpty ? '' : '${token.substring(0, 4)}...'; | ||
| AppLogger.d('VERSE REPOSITORY - Token: $redactedToken (redacted) (empty: ${token.isEmpty})'); | ||
| AppLogger.d('VERSE REPOSITORY - Bearer token: $bearerToken'); | ||
| AppLogger.d( | ||
| 'VERSE REPOSITORY - Fetching verses from $getVersesUrl (sort: ${sortOrder.name})', | ||
| ); | ||
|
|
||
| // Fetch data with authentication header - ensure Bearer prefix has a space | ||
| final privateToken = authToken.accessToken; | ||
| // Fetch data with authentication header |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Improve authentication error handling
- Avoid using global container directly
- Consider throwing an exception instead of returning empty list to make authentication failures explicit
- final authToken = await container.read(authServiceProvider).getToken();
+ // Pass authService through constructor instead
+ final authToken = await _authService.getToken();
if (authToken == null || authToken.accessToken.isEmpty) {
AppLogger.e('No auth token available');
- return [];
+ throw Exception('Authentication required to fetch verses');
}Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In lib/src/features/verse/data/verse_repository.dart around lines 87 to 92,
avoid directly accessing the global container to get the auth token. Instead,
pass the necessary dependencies via constructor or method parameters. Also,
replace returning an empty list on authentication failure with throwing a
specific exception to explicitly signal the failure. This will improve error
handling and make authentication issues clearer.
ericlsimplifi
left a comment
ericlsimplifi
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
LOKTM - rubber stamp. This pr is wayy too big for me to review but looks like a lot of great work!!
…y point are used for production build The `netlify.toml` configuration for building the web application was updated. The build command now uses: - `--flavor=production` to specify the production build flavor. - `--dart-define=MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY=$MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY` to include the Memverse client API key. - `--target lib/main_production.dart` to use the correct main entry point for production builds. The redundant `--dart-define=CLIENT_ID=$MEMVERSE_CLIENT_ID` was removed.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 1
🔭 Outside diff range comments (1)
netlify.toml (1)
3-5: Hard-coded Flutter version3.32.0does not exist on the release server
The URLhttps://storage.googleapis.com/flutter_infra_release/.../flutter_linux_3.32.0-stable.tar.xzwill 404, breaking every Netlify build. Either pin to an actually released tag (e.g.3.22.2) or expose the version as an env var so it can be updated centrally.-FLUTTER_VERSION="3.32.0" +FLUTTER_VERSION="${FLUTTER_VERSION:-3.22.2}" # defaults to latest tested stable
🧹 Nitpick comments (1)
netlify.toml (1)
15-15:--flavorflag is currently ignored forflutter build web
As of Flutter 3.x, build flavors are honoured only for Android/iOS/desktop targets. Supplying--flavoron a web build is a no-op and may start erroring once upstream adds validation. Consider removing it and driving environment-specific logic entirely through--dart-defines.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
📒 Files selected for processing (1)
netlify.toml(1 hunks)
🧰 Additional context used
🧠 Learnings (1)
📓 Common learnings
Learnt from: njwandroid
PR: anirac-tech/memverse_project#23
File: todo_bugsee_android.md:123-132
Timestamp: 2025-04-28T18:16:13.259Z
Learning: The Bugsee integration documentation for Memverse is intended for Flutter applications running on Android, not just native Android applications, and should show both Flutter code and the corresponding native Android code using method channels for communication.
⏰ Context from checks skipped due to timeout of 90000ms. You can increase the timeout in your CodeRabbit configuration to a maximum of 15 minutes (900000ms). (3)
- GitHub Check: Redirect rules - memverse-demo
- GitHub Check: Header rules - memverse-demo
- GitHub Check: Pages changed - memverse-demo
netlify.toml
Outdated
| flutter precache --web | ||
| flutter pub get | ||
| flutter build web --release --dart-define=CLIENT_ID=$MEMVERSE_CLIENT_ID --dart-define=CLIENT_ID=$MEMVERSE_CLIENT_ID --dart-define=POSTHOG_MEMVERSE_API_KEY=$POSTHOG_MEMVERSE_API_KEY --target lib/main_development.dart | ||
| flutter build web --flavor=production --dart-define=MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY=$MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY --release --dart-define=CLIENT_ID=$MEMVERSE_CLIENT_ID --dart-define=POSTHOG_MEMVERSE_API_KEY=$POSTHOG_MEMVERSE_API_KEY --target lib/main_production.dart |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
💡 Verification agent
🧩 Analysis chain
Unquoted --dart-define values risk silent truncation / word-splitting
If any of the API-key or client-ID env vars contain shell-significant chars (=, spaces, $, etc.) the current invocation will pass a broken value to Flutter. Quote each expansion to keep the value intact.
-flutter build web --flavor=production --dart-define=MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY=$MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY --release --dart-define=CLIENT_ID=$MEMVERSE_CLIENT_ID --dart-define=POSTHOG_MEMVERSE_API_KEY=$POSTHOG_MEMVERSE_API_KEY --target lib/main_production.dart
+flutter build web --flavor=production \
+ --dart-define=MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY="$MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY" \
+ --dart-define=CLIENT_ID="$MEMVERSE_CLIENT_ID" \
+ --dart-define=POSTHOG_MEMVERSE_API_KEY="$POSTHOG_MEMVERSE_API_KEY" \
+ --release --target lib/main_production.dart🏁 Script executed:
#!/bin/bash
set -eo pipefail
echo "Displaying netlify.toml around the Flutter build command"
rg -n "flutter build web" -C3 netlify.tomlLength of output: 575
Quote env var expansions in the build command to prevent word-splitting
The flutter build web invocation in netlify.toml (line 15) uses unquoted $… expansions. If any of those values contain spaces or shell metacharacters, the build will receive a malformed --dart-define. Wrap each variable in double quotes.
- File: netlify.toml, line 15
- flutter build web --flavor=production --dart-define=MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY=$MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY --release --dart-define=CLIENT_ID=$MEMVERSE_CLIENT_ID --dart-define=POSTHOG_MEMVERSE_API_KEY=$POSTHOG_MEMVERSE_API_KEY --target lib/main_production.dart
+ flutter build web --flavor=production \
+ --dart-define=MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY="$MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY" \
+ --dart-define=CLIENT_ID="$MEMVERSE_CLIENT_ID" \
+ --dart-define=POSTHOG_MEMVERSE_API_KEY="$POSTHOG_MEMVERSE_API_KEY" \
+ --release --target lib/main_production.dart📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| flutter build web --flavor=production --dart-define=MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY=$MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY --release --dart-define=CLIENT_ID=$MEMVERSE_CLIENT_ID --dart-define=POSTHOG_MEMVERSE_API_KEY=$POSTHOG_MEMVERSE_API_KEY --target lib/main_production.dart | |
| flutter build web --flavor=production \ | |
| --dart-define=MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY="$MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY" \ | |
| --dart-define=CLIENT_ID="$MEMVERSE_CLIENT_ID" \ | |
| --dart-define=POSTHOG_MEMVERSE_API_KEY="$POSTHOG_MEMVERSE_API_KEY" \ | |
| --release --target lib/main_production.dart |
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In netlify.toml at line 15, the flutter build command uses unquoted environment
variable expansions which can cause word-splitting if the variables contain
spaces or special characters. Fix this by wrapping each environment variable
expansion (e.g., $MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY) in double quotes to ensure they are
passed correctly as single arguments to the build command.
The `flutter build web` command was updated to use the correct syntax for specifying the flavor. The equals sign (`=`) between `--flavor` and `production` was removed.
The --flavor flag is not supported for web builds. Environment-specific configurations are handled through --dart-define and --target. See: flutter/flutter#59388
The environment variable `MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY` has been renamed to `MEMVERSE_API_KEY` in the `netlify.toml` file. This change affects the build command for the production environment.
BREAKING CHANGE: OAuth endpoint URL corrected from /api/v1/oauth/token to /oauth/token - Fix OAuth endpoint: use https://www.memverse.com/oauth/token (root level) - Keep other API endpoints at https://www.memverse.com/api/v1/* (versioned) - Add @FormUrlEncoded with @field annotations for proper form data - Add required client_secret parameter to OAuth requests - Add comprehensive API endpoint documentation in docs/api_endpoints.md - Add working curl test commands in curl_commands.md - Fix 301 redirect handling with followRedirects=true and maxRedirects=5 - Remove hardcoded credentials from maestro flows and logs Authentication now works correctly on iOS
✅ Deploy Preview for memverse-demo ready!
To edit notification comments on pull requests, go to your Netlify project configuration. |
This commit introduces a dedicated Netlify serverless function (`/netlify/functions/oauth.js`) to proxy OAuth requests to the Memverse API, resolving CORS errors on the web platform. Key changes: - **New OAuth Proxy:** A new `oauth.js` Netlify function handles requests to `/oauth/*`, forwarding them to `https://www.memverse.com`. This separates OAuth from other API traffic. - **Netlify Configuration:** The `netlify.toml` file is updated with a new redirect rule to route `/oauth/*` requests to the `oauth` function. - **Platform-Specific URLs:** `AuthService` now uses a platform-dependent base URL. For web, it uses the `/oauth` proxy prefix, while native platforms continue to connect directly to the Memverse domain. - **CORS Handling:** Both the `api.js` and the new `oauth.js` functions now handle CORS preflight `OPTIONS` requests. - **Refactoring:** OAuth-specific logging and handling have been removed from the general `api.js` function, which now exclusively manages `/api/v1/*` endpoints.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 4
♻️ Duplicate comments (4)
lib/src/features/verse/data/verse_repository.dart (3)
22-22: Fix type inference for Future.delayed.This issue was flagged in a previous review and still needs to be addressed.
Apply this diff:
- await Future.delayed(const Duration(milliseconds: 100)); + await Future<void>.delayed(const Duration(milliseconds: 100));
69-76: Avoid using global container directly for Talker.This anti-pattern was flagged in a previous review. Consider passing the Talker instance through the constructor to follow proper dependency injection.
90-94: Improve authentication error handling.This was flagged in a previous review. Avoid using the global container for auth service access, and consider throwing an exception instead of silently returning an empty list when authentication fails.
Based on learnings
lib/src/features/auth/data/auth_service.dart (1)
103-105: Do not log raw auth tokens.
AppLogger.d('... token $authToken')emits the entire access token to logs. That’s a critical secret; remove the token from logging entirely.Please update the log line:
- AppLogger.d('LOGIN - Received successful response with token $authToken'); + AppLogger.d('LOGIN - Received successful response from AuthApi');
🧹 Nitpick comments (1)
maestro/flows/login/login.yaml (1)
1-4: Document the environment variable requirement in setup instructions.The comments at the top (lines 1–4) show how to run the test but don't mention the
MEMVERSE_PASSWORDenvironment variable requirement. This could lead to test execution failures for developers unfamiliar with the setup.Consider updating the comments to document how to set the environment variable:
# To launch with different flavors: - # Development: maestro test --app-id com.spiritflightapps.memverse maestro/flows/login.yaml - # Staging: maestro test --app-id com.spiritflightapps.memverse maestro/flows/login.yaml - # Production: maestro test --app-id com.spiritflightapps.memverse maestro/flows/login.yaml + # Development: MEMVERSE_PASSWORD=<password> maestro test --app-id com.spiritflightapps.memverse maestro/flows/login.yaml + # Staging: MEMVERSE_PASSWORD=<password> maestro test --app-id com.spiritflightapps.memverse maestro/flows/login.yaml + # Production: MEMVERSE_PASSWORD=<password> maestro test --app-id com.spiritflightapps.memverse maestro/flows/login.yaml
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
⛔ Files ignored due to path filters (3)
feature_verse_practice_and_scaffold_take_1_ai_prompts.logis excluded by!**/*.logios/Podfile.lockis excluded by!**/*.lockpubspec.lockis excluded by!**/*.lock
📒 Files selected for processing (29)
.gitignore(0 hunks)README.md(1 hunks)curl_commands.md(1 hunks)docs/api_endpoints.md(1 hunks)ios/Flutter/AppFrameworkInfo.plist(1 hunks)ios/Runner.xcodeproj/project.pbxproj(9 hunks)lib/main_production.dart(1 hunks)lib/main_staging.dart(1 hunks)lib/src/common/services/analytics_bootstrap.dart(1 hunks)lib/src/constants/api_constants.dart(1 hunks)lib/src/features/auth/data/api_user_repository.dart(3 hunks)lib/src/features/auth/data/auth_api.dart(1 hunks)lib/src/features/auth/data/auth_api.g.dart(1 hunks)lib/src/features/auth/data/auth_service.dart(1 hunks)lib/src/features/auth/domain/password_token_request.dart(1 hunks)lib/src/features/auth/domain/password_token_request.g.dart(1 hunks)lib/src/features/auth/presentation/providers/auth_providers.dart(2 hunks)lib/src/features/verse/data/verse_repository.dart(2 hunks)macos/Podfile(1 hunks)macos/Runner.xcodeproj/project.pbxproj(9 hunks)maestro/flows/login/login.yaml(1 hunks)netlify/functions/api.js(1 hunks)netlify_deploy.md(2 hunks)plan_of_attack.md(2 hunks)pubspec.yaml(5 hunks)test/auth_service_test.dart(1 hunks)test/features/auth/data/api_user_repository_test.dart(1 hunks)test/features/auth/data/api_user_repository_test.mocks.dart(0 hunks)troubleshoot_signup_api_call.md(8 hunks)
💤 Files with no reviewable changes (2)
- .gitignore
- test/features/auth/data/api_user_repository_test.mocks.dart
✅ Files skipped from review due to trivial changes (2)
- test/auth_service_test.dart
- macos/Podfile
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (1)
- pubspec.yaml
🧰 Additional context used
🧠 Learnings (2)
📚 Learning: 2025-04-28T18:16:13.259Z
Learnt from: njwandroid
Repo: anirac-tech/memverse_project PR: 23
File: todo_bugsee_android.md:123-132
Timestamp: 2025-04-28T18:16:13.259Z
Learning: The Bugsee integration documentation for Memverse is intended for Flutter applications running on Android, not just native Android applications, and should show both Flutter code and the corresponding native Android code using method channels for communication.
Applied to files:
lib/main_staging.darttroubleshoot_signup_api_call.mdREADME.mddocs/api_endpoints.md
📚 Learning: 2025-04-10T23:53:33.307Z
Learnt from: njwandroid
Repo: anirac-tech/memverse_project PR: 13
File: lib/src/features/verse/data/verse_repository.dart:113-117
Timestamp: 2025-04-10T23:53:33.307Z
Learning: The current approach of using generic Exception for missing token cases in verse_repository.dart is acceptable for now. No need to implement domain-specific exceptions like MissingTokenException as suggested.
Applied to files:
lib/src/features/verse/data/verse_repository.dart
🪛 LanguageTool
README.md
[uncategorized] ~61-~61: Did you mean: “By default,”?
Context: ...true ``` AUTOSIGNIN FOR DEMOING - By default (AUTOSIGNIN=true), the app skips login ...
(BY_DEFAULT_COMMA)
curl_commands.md
[formatting] ~146-~146: You have used ‘I’ with an apostrophe, but either the verb is missing or you have not used the corresponding abbreviated form. Consider using one of the suggestions or removing the apostrophe.
Context: ...: Bearer $ACCESS_TOKEN" \ -v Add `-I` for headers-only response: bash cur...
(I_APOSTROPHE_X)
docs/api_endpoints.md
[uncategorized] ~7-~7: Possible missing comma found.
Context: ...ucture The Memverse API has an unusual structure where different types of endpoints use ...
(AI_HYDRA_LEO_MISSING_COMMA)
⏰ Context from checks skipped due to timeout of 90000ms. You can increase the timeout in your CodeRabbit configuration to a maximum of 15 minutes (900000ms). (4)
- GitHub Check: Build and Test
- GitHub Check: Redirect rules - memverse-demo
- GitHub Check: Header rules - memverse-demo
- GitHub Check: Pages changed - memverse-demo
🔇 Additional comments (19)
ios/Runner.xcodeproj/project.pbxproj (1)
486-486: Verify iOS 13.0 deployment target bump is intentional.The iOS minimum deployment target has been updated from 12.0 to 13.0 across all build configurations. This drops support for devices like iPhone 5s, iPhone 6/6 Plus, and older iPads.
Ensure this change aligns with your target audience and is documented in release notes.
Also applies to: 577-577, 668-668, 763-763, 854-854, 943-943, 1040-1040, 1131-1131, 1222-1222
macos/Runner.xcodeproj/project.pbxproj (1)
460-460: Verify macOS 10.15 deployment target bump is intentional.The macOS minimum deployment target has been updated from 10.14 (Mojave) to 10.15 (Catalina) across all build configurations. This drops support for Macs that cannot run Catalina, primarily 2012 and earlier models.
Ensure this change aligns with your target audience and is documented in release notes.
Also applies to: 541-541, 588-588, 699-699, 797-797, 889-889, 979-979, 1069-1069, 1159-1159
maestro/flows/login/login.yaml (1)
14-14: Externalizing credentials: good security practice, but clarify test execution context.Moving the password from hardcoded string to environment variable is a sound security improvement. However, my verification of the CI/CD workflows shows that Maestro tests are not currently integrated into the automated pipeline—the workflows focus on Flutter unit/widget tests, integration tests, and code quality checks.
This change appears to be for local or manual test execution. To avoid confusion:
- Document in the setup comments of
maestro/flows/login/login.yamlwhere and howMEMVERSE_PASSWORDshould be configured (local environment, test runner, etc.)- If Maestro tests will eventually run in CI/CD, ensure the environment variable is configured at that time.
Likely an incorrect or invalid review comment.
ios/Flutter/AppFrameworkInfo.plist (1)
23-24: I'll verify the dependencies now to ensure they're compatible with iOS 13.0.Based on my verification:
Flutter's minimum iOS deployment target as of November 2025 is iOS 13.0, which matches the plist change exactly. The web searches did not reveal any iOS version requirements for the new dependencies (Retrofit and Talker) that exceed iOS 13.0. These are Flutter/Dart packages that would align with Flutter's baseline requirement.
The iOS 13 minimum version aligns with Flutter's current recommendation.
The change from iOS 12.0 to 13.0 is intentional and consistent with Flutter's standard minimum iOS version as of November 2025. No higher requirements were found for the newly added dependencies (Retrofit, Talker).
lib/src/common/services/analytics_bootstrap.dart (1)
29-29: LGTM! More idiomatic null-aware operator.The change from
apiKey?.isNotEmpty == truetoapiKey?.isNotEmpty ?? falseis functionally equivalent but more idiomatic in Dart.lib/main_staging.dart (1)
7-21: LGTM! Clean environment validation with helpful error messaging.The CLIENT_ID validation ensures proper staging configuration, and the debug logging provides useful diagnostic information without exposing sensitive data.
lib/main_production.dart (1)
6-19: LGTM! Environment validation is correct.The CLIENT_ID validation is properly implemented for production. Note that staging (lib/main_staging.dart line 18) logs the API Base URL in debug mode, but production doesn't. This might be intentional for more concise production logs.
netlify_deploy.md (1)
34-36: LGTM! Documentation correctly reflects the versioned API base URL.The documentation updates are consistent with the code changes in lib/src/constants/api_constants.dart.
README.md (1)
14-97: Excellent comprehensive documentation!The updated README provides clear guidance on:
- Required environment variables and where to set them
- Critical distinction between OAuth endpoints (root level) and versioned API endpoints
- AUTOSIGNIN flag usage for demo/QA vs. real authentication
- Complete run/build command examples
The documentation significantly improves developer onboarding and reduces setup friction.
lib/src/constants/api_constants.dart (1)
2-2: No breaking changes to OAuth endpoints from apiBaseUrl modification.The apiBaseUrl change is safe. OAuth endpoints are architecturally isolated—AuthService explicitly instantiates AuthApi with a separate root-level base URL (
https://www.memverse.com), not the versionedapiBaseUrlconstant. The hardcoded URL in the test is a Mockito fallback registration (mock infrastructure), not the actual endpoint. The apiBaseUrl constant is used only for non-OAuth API endpoints and logging, where the/api/v1prefix is correct.Likely an incorrect or invalid review comment.
plan_of_attack.md (1)
62-62: LGTM! API endpoint versioning correctly documented.The updates to use
/api/v1endpoints are consistent with the broader API versioning changes in this PR.Also applies to: 71-71
docs/api_endpoints.md (1)
1-137: Excellent comprehensive API documentation!This documentation clearly explains the dual endpoint structure (OAuth at root vs versioned API paths), authentication flow, and common pitfalls. The examples and implementation notes are particularly helpful.
lib/src/features/auth/domain/password_token_request.dart (1)
1-31: LGTM! Well-structured OAuth token request model.The addition of
clientSecretaligns with the OAuth2 password grant flow requirements documented in the API endpoints file. The JSON serialization annotations correctly map to snake_case field names expected by the API.troubleshoot_signup_api_call.md (1)
12-12: LGTM! Troubleshooting guide correctly updated to versioned endpoints.All curl commands and API references properly updated to use
/api/v1/users. The debugging steps and examples are practical and will help developers troubleshoot signup issues effectively.Also applies to: 39-39, 55-55, 66-66, 73-73, 184-184, 194-194, 260-260
lib/src/features/auth/data/api_user_repository.dart (2)
57-60: Good addition: Redirect handling configuration.Configuring Dio to follow redirects with a reasonable max limit is a good defensive practice, especially given the potential for www/non-www redirects mentioned in the API documentation.
89-92: Simplified endpoint handling improves maintainability.The removal of multiple endpoint attempts in favor of a single standardized pattern (
$_baseUrl/users) makes the code cleaner and aligns with the versioned API approach. The base URL now correctly defaults to the/api/v1path.lib/src/features/auth/domain/password_token_request.g.dart (1)
1-25: Generated code - correctly implements serialization.This generated code properly serializes the updated
PasswordTokenRequestmodel including the newclientSecretfield. No manual modifications needed.test/features/auth/data/api_user_repository_test.dart (1)
31-36: LGTM! Test correctly updated for new API structure.The test properly reflects the updated
ApiUserRepositoryconstructor (removing thebaseUrlparameter) and verifies the correct endpoint URL with the/api/v1version path.Also applies to: 68-72
lib/src/features/auth/data/auth_api.dart (1)
1-38: Excellent implementation of OAuth API client!This Retrofit-based API client correctly implements the OAuth2 password grant flow with:
- Proper
@FormUrlEncodedannotation for the token endpoint- All required fields (
client_secretis correctly included)- Clear inline documentation explaining the endpoint structure differences between OAuth (root level) and regular API calls (versioned paths)
The comments about common pitfalls are particularly valuable for future developers.
| 1. **Wrong OAuth URL**: Don't use `/api/v1/oauth/token` - it will return 500 error | ||
| 2. **Missing client_secret**: OAuth requires both client_id AND client_secret | ||
| 3. **Wrong Content-Type**: OAuth requires form-urlencoded, not JSON | ||
| 4. **WWW prefix**: Always use `www.memverse.com`, not `memverse.com` (server redirects) |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🧩 Analysis chain
Verify www prefix requirement across the codebase.
The documentation states "Always use www.memverse.com, not memverse.com", but I notice some code examples and tests in this PR use memverse.com without the www prefix (e.g., in troubleshoot_signup_api_call.md and test files). Please verify whether the www prefix is actually required, or if the server properly redirects both variants.
🏁 Script executed:
#!/bin/bash
# Search for all memverse.com URL references to check consistency
rg -n "memverse\.com" --type md --type dart -C 2Length of output: 28033
Based on the script execution results, I can now provide a thorough analysis:
Update review comment to reflect actual inconsistencies found.
The documentation requirement in docs/api_endpoints.md line 112 is actually well-founded—the codebase shows a clear pattern:
- Production/main API code consistently uses
www.memverse.comfor OAuth and versioned endpoints (lib/src/constants/api_constants.dart,lib/src/features/auth/data/auth_service.dart,lib/src/features/verse/data/verse_repository.dart) - Environment-specific API endpoints use a different structure:
api.memverse.com,api-stg.memverse.com,api-dev.memverse.com(not www variants) - Real inconsistencies exist in documentation/examples:
troubleshoot_signup_api_call.mdusesmemverse.comwithoutwwwin 8+ curl examples, and some demo files referencememverse.comwithoutwww
The issue is not a false concern—there are multiple instances where memverse.com (without www) appears in example code that contradicts the stated requirement. However, the codebase distinction between:
- Root-level endpoints (
https://www.memverse.com/oauth/token) - Versioned API endpoints (
https://www.memverse.com/api/v1/*) - Environment APIs (
https://api.memverse.com, etc.)
...suggests these are intentional architectural patterns, not just redirect scenarios.
Update troubleshoot_signup_api_call.md (lines 39, 55, 66, 73, 172, 184, 194, 260) and similar files to consistently use https://www.memverse.com/api/v1 instead of https://memverse.com for API calls.
| Future<AuthToken> login(String username, String password, String clientId) async { | ||
| // Dummy user fast-path (bypasses all real auth) | ||
| if (username.toLowerCase() == '[email protected]') { | ||
| isDummyUser = true; | ||
| AppLogger.i('Bypassing authentication: using dummysigninuser'); | ||
| final fakeToken = AuthToken( | ||
| accessToken: 'fake_token', | ||
| tokenType: 'bearer', | ||
| scope: 'user', | ||
| createdAt: DateTime.now().millisecondsSinceEpoch ~/ 1000, | ||
| userId: 0, | ||
| ); | ||
| await saveToken(fakeToken); | ||
| return fakeToken; | ||
| } | ||
| try { | ||
| AppLogger.i('Attempting login with provided credentials'); | ||
| AppLogger.d( | ||
| 'LOGIN - Attempting to log in with username: $username and clientId is non-empty: ${clientId.isNotEmpty}', | ||
| 'LOGIN - Attempting to log in with username: $username and clientId is non-empty: ${clientId.isNotEmpty} and apiKey is non-empty: ${clientSecret.isNotEmpty}', | ||
| ); | ||
|
|
||
| // Change to final from const since kIsWeb is runtime value | ||
| const loginUrl = kIsWeb ? '$webApiPrefix$_tokenPath' : '$apiBaseUrl$_tokenPath'; | ||
| AppLogger.d('LOGIN - Using URL: $loginUrl'); | ||
|
|
||
| try { | ||
| // For web deployment, we need to be careful with FormData | ||
| final requestData = <String, dynamic>{ | ||
| 'grant_type': 'password', | ||
| 'username': username, | ||
| 'password': password, | ||
| 'client_id': clientId, | ||
| }; | ||
|
|
||
| // Use different approach for web vs native for better compatibility | ||
| final response = await _dio.post<Map<String, dynamic>>( | ||
| loginUrl, | ||
| data: kIsWeb ? requestData : FormData.fromMap(requestData), | ||
| options: Options( | ||
| contentType: kIsWeb ? 'application/json' : Headers.formUrlEncodedContentType, | ||
| headers: {'Accept': 'application/json'}, | ||
| validateStatus: (status) => true, | ||
| ), | ||
| ); | ||
|
|
||
| if (response.statusCode == 200) { | ||
| final jsonData = response.data!; | ||
| AppLogger.d('LOGIN - Received successful response with token'); | ||
| final authToken = AuthToken.fromJson(jsonData); | ||
| AppLogger.d('LOGIN - Raw token type: ${jsonData['token_type']}'); | ||
| await saveToken(authToken); | ||
| return authToken; | ||
| } else { | ||
| AppLogger.e( | ||
| 'Login failed with status: ${response.statusCode}, response: ${response.data}', | ||
| ); | ||
| throw Exception('Login failed: ${response.statusCode} - ${response.data}'); | ||
| } | ||
| } catch (dioError) { | ||
| AppLogger.e('Dio login attempt failed, trying with http package', dioError); | ||
| } | ||
|
|
||
| // Fallback to http package with appropriate content type | ||
| final uri = Uri.parse(loginUrl); | ||
| http.Response response; | ||
|
|
||
| if (kIsWeb) { | ||
| // For web, use regular JSON post | ||
| response = await http.post( | ||
| uri, | ||
| headers: {'Content-Type': 'application/json', 'Accept': 'application/json'}, | ||
| body: jsonEncode({ | ||
| 'grant_type': 'password', | ||
| 'username': username, | ||
| 'password': password, | ||
| 'client_id': clientId, | ||
| }), | ||
| ); | ||
| } else { | ||
| // For native, use MultipartRequest | ||
| final request = http.MultipartRequest('POST', uri); | ||
| request.fields.addAll({ | ||
| 'grant_type': 'password', | ||
| 'username': username, | ||
| 'password': password, | ||
| 'client_id': clientId, | ||
| }); | ||
|
|
||
| final streamedResponse = await request.send(); | ||
| response = await http.Response.fromStream(streamedResponse); | ||
| } | ||
|
|
||
| if (response.statusCode == 200) { | ||
| final jsonData = jsonDecode(response.body) as Map<String, dynamic>; | ||
| final authToken = AuthToken.fromJson(jsonData); | ||
| AppLogger.d('LOGIN - Raw token type: ${jsonData['token_type']}'); | ||
| await saveToken(authToken); | ||
| return authToken; | ||
| } else { | ||
| AppLogger.e('Login failed with status: ${response.statusCode}, response: ${response.body}'); | ||
| throw Exception('Login failed: ${response.statusCode} - ${response.body}'); | ||
| } | ||
| final authToken = await _authApi.getBearerToken( | ||
| 'password', | ||
| username, | ||
| password, | ||
| clientId, | ||
| clientSecret, | ||
| ); | ||
| AppLogger.d('LOGIN - Received successful response with token $authToken'); | ||
| AppLogger.d('LOGIN - Raw token type: ${authToken.tokenType}'); | ||
| await saveToken(authToken); | ||
| return authToken; | ||
| } catch (e) { | ||
| AppLogger.e('Login error', e); | ||
| rethrow; | ||
| AppLogger.e('Login failed with AuthApi/Retrofit exception', e); | ||
| throw Exception('Login failed via Retrofit: $e'); | ||
| } | ||
| } | ||
|
|
||
| /// Logs the user out by clearing stored token | ||
| Future<void> logout() async { | ||
| // coverage:ignore-line | ||
| try { | ||
| // coverage:ignore-line | ||
| await _secureStorage.delete(key: _tokenKey); // coverage:ignore-line | ||
| await _secureStorage.delete(key: _tokenKey); | ||
| } catch (e) { | ||
| // coverage:ignore-line | ||
| AppLogger.e('Error during logout', e); // coverage:ignore-line | ||
| rethrow; // coverage:ignore-line | ||
| AppLogger.e('Error during logout', e); | ||
| rethrow; | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Reset the dummy-user flag for real sessions.
isDummyUser is set to true for the dummy login path but never reset. Once a dummy login happens, every subsequent real login keeps the app in “dummy” mode. Reset the flag before real authentication and on logout so real users aren’t misrouted.
Try this adjustment:
- if (username.toLowerCase() == '[email protected]') {
+ final normalizedUsername = username.trim().toLowerCase();
+ if (normalizedUsername == '[email protected]') {
isDummyUser = true;
@@
- try {
+ isDummyUser = false;
+ try {
@@
await _secureStorage.delete(key: _tokenKey);
+ isDummyUser = false;🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In lib/src/features/auth/data/auth_service.dart around lines 75 to 120, the
isDummyUser flag is set true in the dummy login branch but never cleared for
real sessions or on logout; update the real-login path to explicitly set
isDummyUser = false before attempting real authentication (e.g., right before
the try block that calls _authApi.getBearerToken) and ensure logout clears it as
well (set isDummyUser = false after deleting the token or in a finally block so
it always executes even on error).
|
|
||
| // Configuration - Set to your actual API base URL | ||
| const API_BASE_URL = 'https://www.memverse.com'; | ||
| const API_BASE_URL = 'https://www.memverse.com/api/v1'; |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🧩 Analysis chain
Verify OAuth endpoint compatibility with versioned base URL.
Similar to the concern in lib/src/constants/api_constants.dart, the Netlify proxy now uses a base URL with /api/v1. The README.md states that OAuth endpoints are at the root level. Ensure OAuth token requests either:
- Don't use this proxy, or
- Are handled with a special case to route to the root-level endpoint
Run the following script to check if OAuth requests are proxied:
🏁 Script executed:
#!/bin/bash
# Description: Check how OAuth token requests are made and if they use the Netlify proxy
# Search for OAuth token endpoint usage in Dart code
rg -nP --type=dart -C5 '/api/oauth/token|webApiPrefix.*oauth'
# Check if there's special handling for OAuth in the proxy
rg -n 'oauth' netlify/functions/api.jsLength of output: 91
🏁 Script executed:
#!/bin/bash
# Description: Examine OAuth token handling in the Netlify proxy function
# Show the context around the oauth/token checks to understand how they're handled
sed -n '10,30p' netlify/functions/api.js
echo "---"
sed -n '65,80p' netlify/functions/api.jsLength of output: 1444
🏁 Script executed:
#!/bin/bash
# Description: Find where apiPath originates and check for any preprocessing
# Show lines 1-17 to see apiPath extraction/setup
sed -n '1,17p' netlify/functions/api.js
# Check if there's any path normalization or modification before the targetUrl line
rg -n 'apiPath.*=' netlify/functions/api.js | head -20Length of output: 803
OAuth token requests will incorrectly route to versioned endpoint.
The proxy routes all requests through API_BASE_URL which includes /api/v1. OAuth token requests come in as /api/oauth/token, which get stripped to /oauth/token and then appended to the versioned base URL, resulting in https://www.memverse.com/api/v1/oauth/token.
However, per the README.md, OAuth endpoints are at the root level (/oauth/token). The existing oauth/token checks at lines 18 and 72 are logging-only and don't redirect the request.
Required fix: Add special handling to route OAuth token requests to the root endpoint instead of the versioned one.
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In netlify/functions/api.js around line 4 (and the oauth checks at lines 18 and
72), the code builds requests using API_BASE_URL =
'https://www.memverse.com/api/v1' which causes incoming OAuth token requests
(/api/oauth/token or /oauth/token) to be forwarded to /api/v1/oauth/token;
update the request routing to detect OAuth token requests and route them to the
root API host instead of the versioned base. Specifically, when the incoming
path matches /oauth/token or /api/oauth/token, set the target base URL to
'https://www.memverse.com' and forward only '/oauth/token' (not
'/api/v1/oauth/token'), and replace the current logging-only checks at lines 18
and 72 with real routing logic that rewrites the outbound URL accordingly.
Ensure all other paths continue to use API_BASE_URL as before.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 3
♻️ Duplicate comments (4)
lib/src/features/auth/data/auth_service.dart (4)
37-74: Previously flagged: Critical security issue logging secrets.This segment was already identified in previous reviews as logging sensitive OAuth credentials (Authorization headers, passwords, client secrets) in all builds including production. Refer to the earlier comment for the recommended fix.
80-97: Previously flagged: Dummy user implementation security concerns.Multiple security and state management issues with the dummy user implementation were identified in prior reviews, including the static mutable flag, lack of production guards, and userId conflicts.
98-119: Previously flagged: Token logging and missing isDummyUser reset.Earlier reviews identified that line 111 logs the authentication token (security risk) and that the real login path doesn't reset the
isDummyUserflag, causing state persistence issues.
121-129: Previously flagged: Logout doesn't reset isDummyUser.An earlier review noted that the logout method fails to reset the
isDummyUserflag, leading to state persistence across sessions.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
⛔ Files ignored due to path filters (1)
feature_verse_practice_and_scaffold_take_1_ai_prompts.logis excluded by!**/*.log
📒 Files selected for processing (5)
lib/src/constants/api_constants.dart(1 hunks)lib/src/features/auth/data/auth_service.dart(1 hunks)netlify.toml(1 hunks)netlify/functions/api.js(2 hunks)netlify/functions/oauth.js(1 hunks)
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (1)
- netlify.toml
🧰 Additional context used
🧬 Code graph analysis (1)
netlify/functions/oauth.js (1)
netlify/functions/api.js (8)
axios(1-1)queryString(23-23)queryPart(24-24)targetUrl(28-28)headersToForward(32-32)requestData(44-44)response(65-72)responseBody(77-77)
🔇 Additional comments (2)
lib/src/features/auth/data/auth_service.dart (2)
14-35: Clear documentation and testable constructor design.The documentation clarifies the platform-specific OAuth endpoint routing, and the constructor's dependency injection parameters enable straightforward testing.
131-165: Token management implementation is sound.The token storage, retrieval, and status-check methods correctly use
FlutterSecureStoragewith appropriate error handling.
| import 'package:memverse/src/features/auth/domain/auth_token.dart'; | ||
| import 'package:memverse/src/utils/app_logger.dart'; | ||
|
|
||
| const String clientSecret = String.fromEnvironment('MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY'); |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Validate clientSecret at initialization.
clientSecret defaults to an empty string if the environment variable is not set. This leads to silent authentication failures rather than a clear error at startup. Consider validating it's non-empty where AuthService is first constructed or at the start of login.
Add validation near the constructor or at the top of the login method:
AuthService({FlutterSecureStorage? secureStorage, Dio? dio, AuthApi? authApi})
: _secureStorage = secureStorage ?? const FlutterSecureStorage(),
_authApi = authApi ?? AuthApi(
_createDioWithLogging(dio),
baseUrl: kIsWeb ? webOAuthPrefix : 'https://www.memverse.com',
) {
if (clientSecret.isEmpty) {
throw StateError('MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY environment variable must be set');
}
}🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In lib/src/features/auth/data/auth_service.dart around line 12, clientSecret is
read from the environment and may be empty causing silent auth failures;
validate it at AuthService initialization by checking if clientSecret.isEmpty
and throw a clear StateError (or similar) in the constructor (or at start of
login) with message like 'MEMVERSE_CLIENT_API_KEY environment variable must be
set' so the app fails fast and surfaces the missing config.
| class MockAuthService extends AuthService { | ||
| MockAuthService(); | ||
|
|
||
| @override | ||
| Future<bool> isLoggedIn() async => true; | ||
|
|
||
| @override | ||
| Future<AuthToken> login(String username, String password, String clientId) async => AuthToken( | ||
| accessToken: 'mock', | ||
| tokenType: 'Bearer', | ||
| scope: 'user', | ||
| createdAt: DateTime.now().millisecondsSinceEpoch ~/ 1000, | ||
| userId: 0, | ||
| ); | ||
|
|
||
| @override | ||
| Future<void> logout() async {} | ||
|
|
||
| @override | ||
| Future<AuthToken?> getToken() async => AuthToken( | ||
| accessToken: 'mock', | ||
| tokenType: 'Bearer', | ||
| scope: 'user', | ||
| createdAt: DateTime.now().millisecondsSinceEpoch ~/ 1000, | ||
| userId: 0, | ||
| ); | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
MockAuthService lacks production safeguards and has userId conflicts.
The MockAuthService class has several concerns:
- No production guard: Nothing prevents accidental use in release builds, which would bypass all authentication.
- userId collision: Using
userId: 0conflicts with the dummy user and could match real user IDs, potentially causing data corruption. - Missing test annotation: Should be marked
@visibleForTestingto signal intent.
Apply these changes:
+import 'package:flutter/foundation.dart';
+
+@visibleForTesting
class MockAuthService extends AuthService {
- MockAuthService();
+ MockAuthService() {
+ if (kReleaseMode) {
+ throw StateError('MockAuthService must not be used in release builds');
+ }
+ }
@override
Future<AuthToken> login(String username, String password, String clientId) async => AuthToken(
accessToken: 'mock',
tokenType: 'Bearer',
scope: 'user',
createdAt: DateTime.now().millisecondsSinceEpoch ~/ 1000,
- userId: 0,
+ userId: -1, // Negative ID avoids conflicts with real users
);
@override
Future<AuthToken?> getToken() async => AuthToken(
accessToken: 'mock',
tokenType: 'Bearer',
scope: 'user',
createdAt: DateTime.now().millisecondsSinceEpoch ~/ 1000,
- userId: 0,
+ userId: -1,
);
}📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| class MockAuthService extends AuthService { | |
| MockAuthService(); | |
| @override | |
| Future<bool> isLoggedIn() async => true; | |
| @override | |
| Future<AuthToken> login(String username, String password, String clientId) async => AuthToken( | |
| accessToken: 'mock', | |
| tokenType: 'Bearer', | |
| scope: 'user', | |
| createdAt: DateTime.now().millisecondsSinceEpoch ~/ 1000, | |
| userId: 0, | |
| ); | |
| @override | |
| Future<void> logout() async {} | |
| @override | |
| Future<AuthToken?> getToken() async => AuthToken( | |
| accessToken: 'mock', | |
| tokenType: 'Bearer', | |
| scope: 'user', | |
| createdAt: DateTime.now().millisecondsSinceEpoch ~/ 1000, | |
| userId: 0, | |
| ); | |
| } | |
| import 'package:flutter/foundation.dart'; | |
| @visibleForTesting | |
| class MockAuthService extends AuthService { | |
| MockAuthService() { | |
| if (kReleaseMode) { | |
| throw StateError('MockAuthService must not be used in release builds'); | |
| } | |
| } | |
| @override | |
| Future<bool> isLoggedIn() async => true; | |
| @override | |
| Future<AuthToken> login(String username, String password, String clientId) async => AuthToken( | |
| accessToken: 'mock', | |
| tokenType: 'Bearer', | |
| scope: 'user', | |
| createdAt: DateTime.now().millisecondsSinceEpoch ~/ 1000, | |
| userId: -1, // Negative ID avoids conflicts with real users | |
| ); | |
| @override | |
| Future<void> logout() async {} | |
| @override | |
| Future<AuthToken?> getToken() async => AuthToken( | |
| accessToken: 'mock', | |
| tokenType: 'Bearer', | |
| scope: 'user', | |
| createdAt: DateTime.now().millisecondsSinceEpoch ~/ 1000, | |
| userId: -1, | |
| ); | |
| } |
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In lib/src/features/auth/data/auth_service.dart around lines 168-194, update
MockAuthService to prevent accidental production use and avoid real-user ID
collisions: add the @visibleForTesting annotation (import from
package:meta/meta.dart), replace hardcoded userId: 0 with a non-colliding
sentinel like -1 in all returned AuthToken instances, and add a production guard
in the constructor that asserts or throws when running in release (e.g.,
assert(!const bool.fromEnvironment('dart.vm.product')) or throw if const
bool.fromEnvironment('dart.vm.product') is true) so the mock cannot be used in
release builds.
| // Debug OAuth request details (without logging sensitive data) | ||
| console.log('OAuth request detected'); | ||
| console.log('Headers:', JSON.stringify(event.headers)); | ||
| console.log('Content-Type:', event.headers['content-type']); | ||
| console.log('Body present:', !!event.body); | ||
|
|
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Scrub sensitive headers before logging.
OAuth request detected currently dumps JSON.stringify(event.headers), which includes Authorization. Netlify exposes these console logs to the whole team (and can forward them via log drains), so every OAuth client secret and bearer token passing through this proxy ends up in plain text in your logs. This is a security incident waiting to happen.(docs.netlify.com)
Please remove or mask the header logging before shipping:
- console.log('Headers:', JSON.stringify(event.headers));
- console.log('Content-Type:', event.headers['content-type']);
- console.log('Body present:', !!event.body);
+ const { authorization, ...safeHeaders } = event.headers ?? {};
+ console.log('Headers:', JSON.stringify(safeHeaders));
+ console.log('Content-Type:', event.headers?.['content-type']);
+ console.log('Body present:', Boolean(event.body));(If you still need to know whether an auth header was provided, log a boolean flag instead of the raw token.)
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In netlify/functions/oauth.js around lines 31 to 36, the code currently logs
full event.headers (including Authorization) which exposes secrets; replace that
raw header dump with scrubbed/masked header logging: remove
JSON.stringify(event.headers) and instead log a sanitized copy where sensitive
keys (Authorization, Proxy-Authorization, Cookie, Set-Cookie, x-api-key,
x-amz-security-token, etc.) are either removed or replaced with a constant like
"[REDACTED]"; if you need to know whether an auth header was present, log a
boolean (e.g., hasAuth: !!event.headers.authorization) and keep Content-Type and
body-presence logs only. Ensure no actual token/secret values are written to
console before shipping.
