Meeting Minutes for September 18, 2014

Meeting commenced 8:00PM GMT

• Roll call Bob Lockhart (Bob L.)
• Quorum achieved

Proposed agenda

• One Time Pad Proposal (Jerry Stueve)
• KMIP 1.3 Status (Bob L., Judy F.)

Motion to approve Agenda

• Tim Hudson (Tim H.) moves to approve the agenda
• Kiran Thota (Kiran) Seconds
• No objections
• No abstentions
• Agenda approved

One Time Pad (OTP) Proposal (Jerry Stueve)

• Link Name:https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/kmip/download.php/54130/KMIP-One%20Time%20Pad.pdf
• Can you get the OTP value? - John L.
• In our particular case no - a Get would be denied but other options are valid so should not be precluded. - Jerry
• Are there life cycle considerations - Mark Joseph (Mark J.)
• Perhaps a profile to resolve issue of interoperability given the required flexibility - Judy F.
• Does the OTP Apply to streaming? - John L.
• It could be - streaming or non-streaming - either works - that isn't an OTP-specific question - Tim H.
• Isn't the algorithm just XOR? John L.
• It might be or it might not be - there isn't a fixed requirement that this has to be an XOR - the particular algorithm can vary. - Jerry S.
• That makes sense to not call it XOR then (various)
• A profile showing one usage perhaps where it is XOR so interoperability for one context could be tested between vendors would be useful. We need something to test. - Mark J.
• Subhash polls for three companies to support
  • Companies willing to support

  1. Cryptsoft (Tim H.)
  1. P6R (Mark J.)
  1. Thales (Bob L.)
  1. Semper Fortis (Jerry S.)

• General TC acceptance - add the enumeration to KMIP 1.3
• Jerry & Tim separately to create a proposed interoperability profile showing one usage even if that usage isn't a direct match for Jerry's context so testing can be done.

KMIP 1.3 Status (Bob L., Judy F.)

• Bob L. to upload TR31 Key Types specification update at first opportunity
• Bob L. to create proposal for PKCS#12 key format type as previously discussed or it won't make it into version 1.3
• Judy has uploaded changes for key shredding terminology which needs updated in specification
• No separate vote required - will pick this up in the vote once the specification changes from all the proposals have been folded in by Kiran and Tony

== Call for late arrivals - Subhash/Bob L. ==

• No new attendees

Motion to Adjourned

• Tim H. moves to adjourn
• Steve Edwards seconds
• No abstentions
• No objections
• Motion Approved

Meeting Adjourned at 8:45PM GMT